Retirement & pensions / Withdrawal order lab

Arithmetic average versus compound-equivalent return

Averages answer different questions. The withdrawal lab shows the arithmetic mean and a constant compound-equivalent annual return, but does not use either as a forecast. Keep the original path visible when interpreting the result.

Educational illustrations only. No personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. No forecast or recommended withdrawal rate.

Open the free withdrawal order lab →

The arithmetic mean is not compound growth

For −20% and +25%, the arithmetic mean is 2.5%: add the two percentages and divide by two. Yet $100,000 with no withdrawals ends at $100,000 after those returns. A constant 2.5% for two years would instead give $105,062.50. Replacing the path with its arithmetic mean would change the no-withdrawal compound product, so the comparison would no longer isolate order or variability.

How the constant comparator is selected

The lab multiplies the annual gross return factors and finds the equal annual factor with the same product over the entered number of years. In this example, 0.80 × 1.25 = 1, so the compound-equivalent rate is 0%. In symbols: equivalent rate = (product of (1 + each annual rate))^(1 / number of years) − 1. Rates are expressed as decimals in this formula. The implementation uses logarithms for numerical stability.

Why withdrawals can still produce a different answer

The compound-equivalent path matches the gross no-withdrawal product. Once withdrawals occur, the timing of money leaving the portfolio changes the dollars exposed to subsequent returns. A constant 0% path with two $10,000 year-end withdrawals ends at $80,000, between the two orders in the two-year example. That is an illustration; it does not establish that a constant scenario is an expected outcome or a useful confidence interval.

Special cases and limits

If any entered annual return is −100%, the no-withdrawal product is zero, and the lab’s constant-equivalent rate is −100% for every year. That convention is mathematically consistent with a zero compound product but can look very different from a one-year total loss. It is not representative of the original chronology. With one entered year, all three paths coincide. Fees and withdrawal growth are held equal across the paths, and the horizon never silently repeats the entered returns.

Continue with the right next question

Preview a free lesson before choosing an optional structured investing course. Free calculations do not require payment or registration.

References

FCAC: Planning and saving for retirement provides context on spending, inflation and retirement-income assumptions. TD Waterhouse: Sequence of Returns explains the interaction of returns and withdrawals. Its historical examples are not used as data in this lab. Read the lab’s exact calculation convention.

Educational page checked October 7, 2026. No independent professional review is claimed. Report a calculation or explanation issue.