Retirement & pensions / Withdrawal order lab

Why the order of investment returns changes a withdrawal illustration

Two paths can contain the same annual returns and produce different ending balances when money leaves the portfolio between those returns. Use the withdrawal lab to see the arithmetic, rather than treating an average return as a complete retirement plan.

Educational illustrations only. No personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. No forecast or recommended withdrawal rate.

Open the free withdrawal order lab →

Start with a controlled two-year example

Use a fictional $100,000 portfolio, $10,000 withdrawn at each year-end, no fees and no inflation. Path A loses 20% in year one, then gains 25% in year two. After the first loss and withdrawal, $70,000 remains. The second year ends at $77,500 after its withdrawal. Path B reverses those returns. It ends year one at $115,000 and year two at $82,000. Both pay $20,000 in withdrawals. The $4,500 ending-balance gap comes from the interaction between the path and the withdrawals.

Run the no-withdrawal control

Set the withdrawal to zero and retain the two returns. Both orders end at $100,000: $100,000 × 0.80 × 1.25. Multiplication gives the same product in either order. This control separates the path effect from an accidental change to the return set. A beginning-of-year withdrawal convention also changes the displayed values, so keep timing matched when comparing the orders.

Look at more than the last balance

If a path cannot fund a requested withdrawal, the lab pays only what is available and records the remainder as a shortfall. It does not borrow to bridge the gap. A final balance of zero alone does not tell you how much spending was funded before depletion. Read total paid withdrawals, total shortfall and first shortfall year together. This is one entered scenario horizon, not a survival probability or a forecast of a retirement date.

A useful learning experiment

Calculate the example, download its assumptions, then change only the first withdrawal from $10,000 to zero and compare again. Explain why the gap disappears. Restore the withdrawal and change its timing. Record the convention with the result. Reversing a path is a teaching comparison, not a claim that one future sequence is more likely. TD’s sequence-of-returns explainer discusses withdrawals alongside changing investment returns; the lab’s fictional arithmetic is independently specified here.

Continue with the right next question

Preview a free lesson before choosing an optional structured investing course. Free calculations do not require payment or registration.

References

FCAC: Planning and saving for retirement provides context on spending, inflation and retirement-income assumptions. TD Waterhouse: Sequence of Returns explains the interaction of returns and withdrawals. Its historical examples are not used as data in this lab. Read the lab’s exact calculation convention.

Educational page checked October 7, 2026. No independent professional review is claimed. Report a calculation or explanation issue.