Retirement & pensions / Withdrawal order lab

Beginning versus end-of-year withdrawals: choose a convention

A withdrawal amount is incomplete without a timing convention. The lab offers one withdrawal per year, either before the annual return and fee or after them. It does not model a monthly spending schedule.

Educational illustrations only. No personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. No forecast or recommended withdrawal rate.

Open the free withdrawal order lab →

A one-year audit

Begin with $100,000, assume a 10% annual return and request a $10,000 withdrawal. With no fee, withdrawing before the return leaves $90,000 to grow, ending at $99,000. Withdrawing after the return lets $100,000 grow to $110,000 before paying $10,000, ending at $100,000. The $1,000 gap comes from this convention, not from a different return rate or a different withdrawal amount.

Where the fee sits

For the before-return setting, the lab first pays the withdrawal from the opening balance, then applies the return and then charges the annual percentage fee against that post-return balance. For the after-return setting, it applies the return, charges the fee, then pays the withdrawal. A 1% fee on a $110,000 post-return balance is $1,100. Real fee schedules may use different dates, balances and charges; read the actual fee disclosure rather than treating this simplified convention as a contract.

Keep both scenarios on the same clock

Reversing the return list while keeping timing fixed isolates the ordering comparison. Changing timing at the same time answers a broader question and makes the cause of any difference harder to explain. Compare one assumption at a time and retain a written record. The lab’s annual results are not a daily ledger, and its apparent year-one funding does not guarantee that money is available on the actual date a bill must be paid.

What to bring to a more detailed discussion

Record how often actual withdrawals occur, whether income arrives before the relevant bills, whether a withdrawal represents gross cash leaving an account or net spending, and how fees are deducted. The lab excludes taxes and benefit eligibility. It cannot translate a pretax registered-account withdrawal into after-tax household spending. Use the payday cash-flow tool for dates of incoming and outgoing cash; use an appropriately qualified professional for account-specific consequences.

Continue with the right next question

Preview a free lesson before choosing an optional structured investing course. Free calculations do not require payment or registration.

References

FCAC: Planning and saving for retirement provides context on spending, inflation and retirement-income assumptions. TD Waterhouse: Sequence of Returns explains the interaction of returns and withdrawals. Its historical examples are not used as data in this lab. Read the lab’s exact calculation convention.

Educational page checked October 7, 2026. No independent professional review is claimed. Report a calculation or explanation issue.