Retirement & pensions / Withdrawal order lab

Read depletion and withdrawal shortfalls without false certainty

A zero ending balance and an unpaid withdrawal are different events. The withdrawal lab reports them separately, caps the balance at zero and never supplies a loan or a negative portfolio to fund spending.

Educational illustrations only. No personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. No forecast or recommended withdrawal rate.

Open the free withdrawal order lab →

Exact exhaustion can still fund that year

Start with $20,000, request $10,000 each year and use 0% returns, fees and withdrawal growth for three years. Years one and two pay the full $10,000. The ending balance reaches zero in year two. Year three pays zero and records a $10,000 shortfall. The first shortfall is year three, even though exhaustion was year two. Reading only the ending-balance label would miss that distinction.

A partial payment is explicitly reported

Start with $15,000 under the same assumptions. Year one pays $10,000, leaving $5,000. Year two pays $5,000 and records a $5,000 shortfall. Later years cannot recover the portfolio because this model has no contributions and a zero balance earns zero dollars even when the return percentage is positive. The lab keeps all entered years in the table so unpaid requests remain visible after depletion.

A loss can deplete the balance after a paid withdrawal

Under the before-return convention, a fully funded withdrawal may occur before a −100% annual return wipes out what remains. With the after-return convention, that same loss happens before the withdrawal, leaving nothing to pay it. Neither outcome represents the actual timing of a market loss within a calendar year. This boundary example checks the annual model’s order of operations.

What this scenario cannot conclude

The lab does not calculate a probability of funding future spending, run historical simulations or identify a safe withdrawal rate. It does not assess longevity, taxes, account withdrawal restrictions, asset allocation, health costs or other income. A funded five-year path is only a funded five-year path under the entered assumptions. Take the assumptions record and the shortfall years into a broader review rather than treating the ending balance as a retirement approval.

Continue with the right next question

Preview a free lesson before choosing an optional structured investing course. Free calculations do not require payment or registration.

References

FCAC: Planning and saving for retirement provides context on spending, inflation and retirement-income assumptions. TD Waterhouse: Sequence of Returns explains the interaction of returns and withdrawals. Its historical examples are not used as data in this lab. Read the lab’s exact calculation convention.

Educational page checked October 7, 2026. No independent professional review is claimed. Report a calculation or explanation issue.