Same returns. Different order. What changes when you withdraw?
Explore how a portfolio pays withdrawals under a sequence of annual return assumptions. Keep the same starting money and return set, reverse their order, and see each year’s arithmetic.
Free without registration. All amounts in CAD. Educational illustrations only; no personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. This is not a market forecast, retirement approval, survival probability or recommended withdrawal rate.
Change the path, keep the comparison fair
Use fictional values or your own assumptions. Enter one percentage for each year, in order. A minus sign means a loss. The lab compares your order, the reverse order and a constant compound-equivalent path. No market history is supplied.
Showing the fictional five-year example.
Calculated assumptions
$100,000.00 starting portfolio · $10,000.00 first withdrawal · 0% annual increase · 0% annual fee · withdrawal after return and fee · 5 years
Entered annual returns: -20%, 25%, 5%, -10%, 15%
Arithmetic mean 3%. Compound-equivalent annual return 1.68% before fees and withdrawals. These describe the entered path; neither forecasts future returns.
Compare outcomes within this entered horizon
Entered order
Ending portfolio
$52,373.12
Ending portfolio in starting-year dollars
$52,373.12
Total nominal withdrawals paid
$50,000.00
Total nominal withdrawal shortfall
$0.00
Fees charged in this model
$0.00
First year withdrawal not fully funded
None within entered years
First year ending balance reaches zero
None within entered years
Reverse order
Ending portfolio
$60,725.00
Ending portfolio in starting-year dollars
$60,725.00
Total nominal withdrawals paid
$50,000.00
Total nominal withdrawal shortfall
$0.00
Fees charged in this model
$0.00
First year withdrawal not fully funded
None within entered years
First year ending balance reaches zero
None within entered years
Constant compound-equivalent
Ending portfolio
$56,968.86
Ending portfolio in starting-year dollars
$56,968.86
Total nominal withdrawals paid
$50,000.00
Total nominal withdrawal shortfall
$0.00
Fees charged in this model
$0.00
First year withdrawal not fully funded
None within entered years
First year ending balance reaches zero
None within entered years
Entered order minus reverse order ending balance: -$8,351.87. A larger ending balance does not establish a suitable retirement plan. Paid withdrawals and shortfalls must be read alongside it.
Audit a year at a time
Entered order — nominal CAD unless specified
Year
Annual return
Opening balance
Requested withdrawal
Paid withdrawal
Shortfall
Fee charged
Ending balance
Ending in starting-year dollars
1
-20%
$100,000.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
$70,000.00
$70,000.00
2
25%
$70,000.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
$77,500.00
$77,500.00
3
5%
$77,500.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
$71,375.00
$71,375.00
4
-10%
$71,375.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
$54,237.50
$54,237.50
5
15%
$54,237.50
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
$52,373.12
$52,373.12
Return to the same assumptions
Downloading and importing are optional. Files stay on your device until you share them. This lab does not connect to financial accounts, send inputs to a server or save them between visits. Reloading resets the example. Avoid entering account numbers or identifying details.
Keep a copy of this result
Immediate PDF download with your current inputs, results and assumptions. No email or account required.
Free output stays visible. Email learning sessions, where available, use a separate optional choice.
Exact method and assumptions
One entered percentage represents one full year. The model uses each year once; it does not extend or repeat the path.
Requested withdrawal for year n = first withdrawal × (1 + annual increase / 100)^(n − 1).
Before-return timing: pay the withdrawal from the opening balance, multiply what remains by (1 + annual return / 100), then deduct the annual percentage fee from that post-return balance.
After-return timing: multiply the opening balance by the annual return factor, deduct the annual percentage fee, then pay the withdrawal.
A paid withdrawal cannot exceed available money. The rest is an explicit shortfall. The portfolio cannot borrow or go negative, and no contribution replenishes it.
Starting-year purchasing power = year-end balance ÷ (1 + annual increase / 100)^n. The same assumption represents spending inflation and portfolio discounting.
The reversed path contains exactly the same annual return set in reverse chronological order. The constant path has the same gross compound product before withdrawals and fees. It is not the arithmetic mean. A −100% return makes that product zero; the constant comparator then uses −100% in every year.
FCAC: Planning and saving for retirement supplies background on spending, inflation and income. The annual convention above is this tool’s own mathematical model.
Balances remain unrounded during calculation; display rounds to cents. Fees are charged once a year in this illustration. Actual taxes, transaction charges, account rules, other income, pension benefits, contribution limits, asset allocation, daily cash flows and uncertain lifespan are excluded. No historical returns or probabilities are included. Inputs beyond the numerical bounds are rejected rather than silently changed.
A funded horizon is only a funded horizon under these assumptions. None of the paths establishes how much a household can safely withdraw, and a positive last balance says nothing about later years that were not entered.
Try a controlled learning exercise
Use $100,000, a $10,000 annual withdrawal, no increase or fee, after-return timing, and two annual returns: −20%, +25%. The entered order ends at $77,500; the reverse ends at $82,000. Both pay $20,000. Set withdrawals to zero and both orders end at $100,000. Keep other fields matched so the difference has a clear explanation.
FCAC: Planning and saving for retirement explains spending, inflation and income considerations. TD Waterhouse: Sequence of Returns discusses returns alongside withdrawals. The lab uses user-entered or explicitly fictional returns and its own documented annual convention, not the historical dataset in that document.
Clean a fictional pay stub, audit a retirement illustration and read a workplace match. Worked answers, correction paths and two reusable prompts are included.