Before-and-after checks & final exercise →
THE NORTH LEARNING STUDIO
See it. Test it. Keep the reasoning.
Compare debt by cost, obligations and consequences.
01 / WATCH THE VISUAL CASE
Understanding different types of debt
1:43 · Synthetic narration · English captions · Fictional worked examples
Complete transcript
Compare an equal extra dollar
Compare debt by cost, obligations and consequences.
See the mechanism.
Debt differs by interest rate, whether it is secured, repayment terms and consequences of missed payments. A mortgage is secured against property; unsecured borrowing does not have that same specific collateral arrangement.
Follow the worked case.
Compare an equal extra payment of one hundred dollars. At a fixed twenty percent annual rate, that amount avoids twenty dollars of simple interest over one year. At five percent it avoids five dollars. Different balance sizes do not change the interest saved per equal extra dollar under these assumptions.
Pause and predict.
Which interpretation fits the worked case? Option one: A lower rate saves more interest for the same extra dollar. Option two: At unchanged rates, the same extra dollar avoids more interest against the 20% debt than the 5% debt. Pause and choose before continuing.
Read the result carefully.
At unchanged rates, the same extra dollar avoids more interest against the 20% debt than the 5% debt. A consolidation comparison must also account for fees, term, security and the ability to sustain payments; a lower payment alone does not establish a lower total cost.
Now test one change.
Change equal extra payment. Compare the result while leaving the other assumptions unchanged. In the practice area, use the same worked case, record what remains unresolved, and download your decision brief. This is education, not a forecast or personal financial advice.
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING
Which interpretation fits the worked case?
02 / EXPLORE THE SAME WORKED CASE
Compare an equal extra dollar
The film’s starting case, ready for your own comparison.
Empty or invalid assumptions revert to the last accepted value when you leave the field. Negative amounts represent a shortfall.
Assumptions and limits
One-year simple-interest comparison only; fixed rates, no fees, minimum-payment or prepayment restrictions modeled. Figures are rounded for display; full precision is used in the illustration.
03 / INTERPRET THE TRADE-OFF
Explain the change in your own words.
Change equal extra payment. Compare the result while leaving the other assumptions unchanged. Explain why the result changes, name one unresolved fact and choose a next verification.
Compare with the worked reasoning
At unchanged rates, the same extra dollar avoids more interest against the 20% debt than the 5% debt. A consolidation comparison must also account for fees, term, security and the ability to sustain payments; a lower payment alone does not establish a lower total cost.
04 / KEEP A DECISION BRIEF
Leave with a next step.
These fields stay in this page’s memory and clear when you leave. Download before navigating away. Existing course notes and saved assessments remain separate. A review date does not create a reminder.
Sources and educational scope
Original fictional teaching examples, not forecasts or individual financial, pension, tax, legal or investment advice. Source dates remain those shown in the written lesson; no independent professional review is implied.
By the end of this lesson
- Compare repayment methods under equal assumptions.
- Distinguish lower payments from lower total repayment.
The idea in plain language
Debt differs by interest rate, whether it is secured, repayment terms and consequences of missed payments. A mortgage is secured against property; unsecured borrowing does not have that same specific collateral arrangement. Variable rates can change, while a promotional rate may expire.
How the pieces fit together
Two common educational repayment methods focus extra payments on either the highest interest rate or the smallest balance, while contractual minimums remain due on other debts. The first reduces interest under consistent assumptions; the second creates earlier account payoffs. Neither description is an individual debt strategy.
A useful distinction
Before comparing methods, consider arrears, essential expenses, penalties, legal obligations and whether a proposed consolidation extends the borrowing period. A lower payment can conceal higher lifetime interest. Serious payment difficulty can require a qualified credit counsellor or licensed insolvency trustee rather than a calculator.
A hypothetical example
For two fictional balances of $1,000 at 20% and $500 at 5%, directing the same extra dollar to the 20% balance avoids more interest per dollar, if rates and terms remain unchanged.
Work through the case
Maya compares a $1,000 balance at 20% and a $500 balance at 5%. All minimum payments remain due; the comparison concerns an extra $100 only.
For one year at unchanged simple rates, $100 less debt at 20% avoids roughly $20 of interest; at 5%, roughly $5. The $15 difference explains the rate-first method under these assumptions.
The balance-first method would direct the extra amount to the $500 debt for an earlier payoff milestone. That psychological benefit does not reverse the interest arithmetic.
Offer A requires $250 for 24 months: $6,000 total. Offer B requires $180 for 36 months: $6,480 total. Assuming the same amount borrowed and no other charges, B is $70 cheaper monthly but $480 more in total. Arrears, secured debts, fees and penalties can change priorities.
Try it yourself
A replacement offer is $170 for 36 months plus a $200 fee. Compare with A.
Use paper or your own notes. Try the calculation or explanation before opening the solution.
Show the worked solution
$170 × 36 + $200 = $6,320, which is $320 more than A. Check whether the fee is financed, whether rates change and whether the offers cover identical debts.
GO DEEPER
Compare the same debt over the same horizon
A fair borrowing comparison starts with the same amount refinanced, the same starting date and a clearly stated horizon. Compare cash paid, fees and the balance still owed at that horizon. A low payment can look attractive simply because more debt remains afterward. Secured borrowing also changes what can be at risk if payments are missed; that consequence is separate from the interest calculation.
Distinguish a cash-flow problem from a total-cost problem. An offer can ease this month’s payment and increase lifetime cost. Rate-first and balance-first repayment examples assume required payments continue on every debt; they do not settle arrears, legal deadlines or secured-debt consequences. When the monthly budget cannot meet obligations, a comparison table is not a complete remedy.
Test your reasoning
Answer in your own words or work the numbers before revealing the explanation. These practice questions do not change your saved lesson result.
1. A requires 24 payments of $300. B requires 36 of $220 plus a $150 upfront fee. For the same debt, how do their totals differ?
Check answer 1 and reasoning
A totals $7,200. B totals $8,070. B is $80 less monthly but $870 more in total, assuming no other amounts.
2. Over 12 months, A pays $3,600 and leaves $4,000 debt. B pays $2,640 and leaves $5,300 debt, plus a $150 fee. Compare cash paid plus remaining debt.
Check answer 2 and reasoning
A: $7,600. B: $8,090, or $490 more. This common-horizon illustration is not a discounted present-value calculation.
FROM LESSON TO PRACTICE
Financing comparison workbench
Compare the default fictional offers over the same horizon. Record cash paid and debt remaining separately before changing a loan term.
Open activity in a new tabBring back one observation: A monthly saving can be accompanied by a larger remaining obligation.
Use fictional inputs. Return to this lesson tab to compare your observation and continue learning.
TRY THE LEARNING EXPERIENCE · ABOUT 5 MINUTES
One household. Three car options.
What does the payment leave out?
Read a short lesson, change the numbers, explain the trade-offs and check your reasoning. The complete demo is free, with no sign-in.
Financial Literacy 101 adds the full curriculum, worked cases, knowledge assessments, final exercise and saved course progress. Pro tools are separate purchases.
Put the idea into words
List the missing facts needed to understand a consolidation offer beyond its advertised monthly payment.
Open the learning tools ↗CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING
Using the stated offers, what accurately describes B ($180 × 36) versus A ($250 × 24)?
Free practice stays in this page. Sign in to save progress across visits. Unlimited attempts. Completion is not a professional certification.
North of Numbers provides financial education and educational tools only. Nothing on this website constitutes financial, investment, tax, legal, accounting, mortgage, insurance or other professional advice. Information and calculator results are general and illustrative in nature and may not apply to your individual circumstances. Hypothetical outcomes are not predictions or guarantees.
Applied cases and practice reviewed September 24, 2026. Core lesson reviewed 2026-09-18. Information may change. Official sources for further reading:
Who wrote and checked this? Sources and corrections
Published by: North of Numbers, an independent education platform. Author attribution: a named author and their qualifications have not been verified for publication. Qualified review: no independent professional review is documented.
The core lesson’s recorded review date is . Lesson source links and recorded dates identify the teaching references. They do not establish a reviewer’s identity, credentials or professional approval.
Found an error? Report a correction by email or use Contact. Include the page link, the statement and a supporting source. Please omit personal financial details.