Start here
How can a Coast FI projection be stress-tested?
Keep the starting assets and target explicit, then change one assumption at a time: real growth, retirement date, spending needs or portfolio withdrawals. Next combine adverse assumptions that could occur together. Measure the resulting shortfall and the contributions, spending changes or additional work needed to address it. A later retirement can help, but its benefits depend on continued earning capacity and revised pension estimates. Scenario calculations describe consequences; they do not assign probabilities or guarantee a result.
What you’ll learn
- Test lower growth and interrupted earnings as separate risks before combining them.
- More working years can improve funding but are not a guaranteed option.
- Translate a shortfall into explicit adjustments rather than changing the return assumption to make it disappear.
A threshold is only as strong as its assumptions
A Coast FI calculation can look reassuring because its output is a single number. The underlying promise is much less simple: existing assets must remain invested, earned income must cover living costs, and growth must be sufficient before retirement begins. Stress testing asks what happens when those conditions weaken.
It does not mean searching for a scenario in which every imaginable disaster occurs. Useful tests connect a particular uncertainty to a financial consequence and a possible response. The response should be measurable, such as an annual contribution or revised spending amount, rather than a general intention to be more careful.
Establish a case that can be reproduced
Assume a fictional forty-year-old has $450,000 of retirement investments and wants $950,000 at sixty-five. Both balances use today's Canadian purchasing power and the same tax basis. Assume annual effective returns after investment costs and any tax drag relevant during accumulation. Any future withdrawal-tax allowance is already reflected consistently in the target.
There are no contributions or withdrawals in the initial projection. Annual growth is applied twenty-five times. Current expenses are funded entirely from earnings, and emergency savings are held separately. These assumptions describe a teaching model, not a forecast or a recommended portfolio.
At a constant 3% real annual return, $450,000 × 1.03^25 produces approximately $942,200. That is about $7,800 below the target. The plan is close under this assumption, but “close” should not be relabelled “fully funded.” It also gives little information about the consequences of a different growth path.
Change one assumption at a time
Start with growth. The 2026 Projection Assumption Guidelines, published in April 2026, calls for sensitivity analysis and review of assumptions. Its published nominal, before-fee rates are not the real, after-cost teaching rates used here. Keeping those definitions separate makes the following comparison interpretable.
| Scenario with $450,000 initially | Years of growth | Ending amount, rounded | Shortfall versus $950,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% real annual growth | 25 | $942,200 | $7,800 |
| 2% real annual growth | 25 | $738,273 | $211,727 |
| 1% real annual growth | 25 | $577,094 | $372,906 |
| 2% real annual growth, later retirement | 30 | $815,113 | $134,887 |
The table does not rank these scenarios by likelihood. It shows exposure to the growth assumption. A person cannot choose the market return after seeing the result, whereas the saving rate or target spending may be partly adjustable. Distinguishing controllable choices from uncertain outcomes keeps the exercise useful.
Calculate what additional saving would require
Under the 2% return and twenty-five-year period, the projected gap is approximately $211,727 at retirement. Suppose the person responds with equal annual contributions made at each year-end. Those contributions also earn 2% real annually; their purchasing-power amount stays constant, which means nominal contributions would rise with inflation.
The future value of those contributions equals annual contribution × [(1.02^25 − 1) ÷ 0.02]. Solving for the contribution gives approximately $6,610 per year. Using the unrounded amount in the model closes the projected gap. A rounded annual payment may leave a small rounding difference.
This scenario is no longer pure coasting because new money is being added. That is not a conceptual failure. It is a concrete alternative to compare with lower spending or more work. The important question is whether the household budget can sustain the contribution, including in an ordinary bad year.
Test an early loss without overstating sequence effects
Now suppose the first year's real return is negative 20%, followed by twenty-four years at 3%. The first year leaves $360,000. The later growth produces approximately $731,806 at the original retirement date. The shortfall is about $218,194.
This is a different return path from twenty-five years of constant 3% growth. It is not evidence that a 20% decline will occur, nor that recovery will follow the stated pace. FCAC's Basics of investing identifies horizon and risk tolerance as relevant considerations; a spreadsheet cannot replace an assessment of the investments actually held.
There is a useful mathematical distinction. If there are no deposits or withdrawals, rearranging an identical set of annual percentage returns does not change the final balance: the same growth factors multiply together. Timing still affects interim balances and decisions. Once money enters or leaves the portfolio, the order of returns can also change the final amount.
Add the risk that earnings stop covering expenses
Coasting depends on employment or another income source paying current bills. Suppose a work interruption forces a $12,000 portfolio withdrawal at the end of year ten. Under the original constant 3% growth assumption, that reduces the year-twenty-five balance by approximately $18,696: $12,000 × 1.03^15.
The lost ending value includes both the cash withdrawn and its foregone growth. A separate emergency reserve might prevent that withdrawal, but only if it is available and sufficient. Money cannot be counted simultaneously in the untouched retirement balance and the reserve used to cover the interruption.
A combined test could include weaker returns and a loss of earnings at the same time. Calculate that case directly rather than adding rounded losses from unrelated scenarios. Taxes on withdrawals, changed benefits or replacement borrowing could introduce further costs that the simple example leaves out.
Evaluate later retirement as a conditional response
Five extra years at 2% growth increase the projection from about $738,273 to $815,113. The improvement is approximately $76,840, but it still leaves a substantial gap. More time helps in this example; it does not automatically repair every shortfall.
Later retirement could also shorten the withdrawal period or change pension income. Those effects require a revised retirement target, not only more compounding. CPP retirement pension: how much you could receive explains that pension amounts depend on earnings, contributions and claim age. Recalculate the relevant estimate rather than assuming the additional years preserve every earlier assumption.
Continued employment is also uncertain. Health, caregiving responsibilities and labour demand can limit the ability to work longer. Treat a later date as one response to investigate, with alternatives, instead of a guaranteed source of financial capacity.
A learning exercise with a decision record
Keep the original twenty-five-year period, but reduce the target to $850,000. At 3% real growth, the projected $942,200 exceeds that target by approximately $92,200. At 2%, the projected $738,273 falls short by approximately $111,727. The same current assets support different conclusions under the two assumptions.
Write down what spending change would justify the lower target and whether it is genuinely acceptable. Then choose a review trigger, such as changed work plans, a revised pension estimate or a material spending increase. A stress test becomes useful when its results lead to explicit choices and review points, rather than a favourable number chosen once and forgotten.
Evidence behind the explanation
Sources & checks
Linked sources were consulted on October 28, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.
- 2026 Projection Assumption GuidelinesFP Canada Standards Council and Institute of Financial Planning · Accessed 2026-10-28
April 2026 guidance distinguishes nominal before-fee assumptions and calls for sensitivity analysis and review; no empirical withdrawal result quoted.
- Basics of investingFinancial Consumer Agency of Canada · Accessed 2026-10-28
Investment objectives, horizon, risk, fees and tax treatment.
- CPP retirement pension: how much you could receiveService Canada · Accessed 2026-10-28
Pension amounts depend on age, earnings and contribution history; estimates are not universal maximums.
When this article needs another review
- Material changes to growth, fees, target spending, employment or pension assumptions.
- A portfolio withdrawal, major market change or revised retirement date.
Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.
About this educational article
Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.
This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.