Financial independence · Article 75

An annual FIRE and Coast FI review: update the plan without chasing markets

Build an annual FIRE or Coast FI review around spending, pensions, taxes and time, with a Canadian worked example that separates facts from assumptions.

Published by North of Numbers · · 7 min read

Educational purposes only. Examples are fictional and in Canadian dollars unless stated otherwise.

Start here

How can I review a FIRE or Coast FI plan without reacting to every market move?

Review the relationship between spending, available assets, future income and time on a regular schedule and after major life changes. Keep a dated record of assumptions, compare figures in consistent purchasing power, and test alternative outcomes. A changed account balance does not automatically require a changed strategy. A useful review explains why an input changed, separates accumulation from retirement withdrawals, and shows the practical consequences of each possible response.

What you’ll learn

  • A dated assumptions register separates verified facts from estimates and lifestyle choices.
  • Compare balances, spending and contributions in the same purchasing power and on a consistent tax basis.
  • Recheck pension estimates and the withdrawal phase when work patterns or retirement dates change.

Review the plan, not just the account balance

An annual financial independence review asks whether the relationship between resources, spending and time still makes sense. A portfolio total is only one input. A new dependent, different work hours, an approaching pension date or a lasting change in housing costs can matter more than a single year's market return.

Choose a regular review month so that statements, spending records and assumptions can be compared consistently. Review sooner after a material life event. This is a planning cadence, not an instruction to trade annually. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada's retirement checklist provides a useful starting inventory of income, expenses and other retirement considerations.

Keep the previous version. Without it, a spreadsheet can quietly change its assumptions until the desired answer reappears. Record what changed, why it changed and which decisions depend on it.

Make a dated assumptions register

For each input, distinguish an observed fact from an estimate. A statement balance has a valuation date. A future return is an assumption. A pension estimate has calculation conditions. An intention to work until 65 is a choice that may change.

InputRecordQuestion at review
Investment assetsBalance, account type, fees and dateIs the money available for this goal?
Household spendingEssential, discretionary and irregular costsIs the change temporary or recurring?
Future incomePension source, start date and tax basisDoes it reflect the proposed work pattern?
Investment growthNominal or real, before or after feesIs the assumption internally consistent?
Retirement timingAge, remaining years and possible rangeHas the funding horizon changed?
ContingenciesCash reserves, care and dependent needsAre these already counted elsewhere?

Exclude money earmarked for near-term expenses from a long-term compounding example. Do not count the same cash reserve twice. A home value also needs a specific plan for turning equity into spendable resources before it belongs in a retirement funding calculation.

Keep the comparison in the same dollars

Suppose the first plan uses October 2026 purchasing power. At the next review, express the new balance, retirement spending and contributions in that same purchasing power before comparing them with the old figures. Alternatively, rebuild the entire comparison in the new year's dollars. Mixing the two creates a false improvement or shortfall.

Real returns account for inflation; they do not automatically account for fees or taxes. Write down which deductions have already been made. The 2026 Projection Assumption Guidelines, published by FP Canada and the Institute of Financial Planning, support disciplined long-term assumptions and sensitivity analysis. They are not a guarantee of results for any particular portfolio.

The examples below use invented, smooth real returns after fees. Their purpose is to isolate the mechanics. Actual market paths fluctuate, and these calculations do not establish a safe withdrawal rate.

Worked example: Mira's original Coast FI estimate

Mira is 40 and plans to fund retirement from age 65. She has $300,000 invested, while earnings cover all current living costs. For this simplified example, all investments are assumed to be held in a valid TFSA, with no contributions or withdrawals during the next 25 years. This balance is not an assertion about anyone's contribution room.

CRA explains that TFSA investment income and withdrawals are generally tax-free. That assumption makes portfolio balances and spending comparable here. An RRSP balance of the same size would require a separate tax model.

Mira initially estimates $48,000 of annual after-tax retirement spending and $18,000 of after-tax pension income starting at 65. The pension figure is a placeholder, not a government entitlement or maximum. The resulting portfolio spending gap is $30,000 a year.

Using 4% solely as an illustrative target-setting input, $30,000 ÷ 0.04 gives $750,000. At an assumed 4% annual real return after fees, $300,000 × 1.04^25 becomes approximately $799,751. The implied Coast FI threshold today is $750,000 ÷ 1.04^25, or $281,338.

The arithmetic places Mira above that threshold. It does not prove that she can stop saving safely: both the accumulation assumption and the eventual withdrawal plan remain uncertain.

One year later: separate three different changes

At 41, Mira's portfolio is worth $290,000 in the original plan's purchasing power. She now has 24 years until retirement. A recurring expense raises the projected annual portfolio spending gap to $31,200. Keeping the same illustrative 4% division input produces a revised target of $780,000.

The annual review also includes a lower-growth stress scenario of 3% real after fees. This is a deliberate sensitivity test, not a forecast inferred from one disappointing year.

CalculationResult, rounded
$290,000 × 1.03^24$589,510 at age 65
$780,000 − $589,510$190,490 projected shortfall
$780,000 ÷ 1.03^24$383,708 required today under that scenario
$290,000 × 1.04^24$743,358 if the original growth assumption is retained

Even the original 4% growth assumption now falls short of the revised target. The lower balance, one less compounding year, increased spending and lower stress-test return have separate effects. Showing both return scenarios prevents the review from blaming everything on the latest market movement.

Compare possible responses without manufacturing certainty

Mira can use the model to understand choices. Under the 3% scenario, a constant real contribution made at each year-end would need to be about $5,533 annually for 24 years to close the modelled gap. The formula is: annual contribution = [target − current balance × (1 + return)^years] × return ÷ [(1 + return)^years − 1].

These contributions would rise with inflation in nominal dollars. They also require actual income and available contribution room; the calculation creates neither. This is an arithmetic scenario, not a recommendation that Mira contribute that amount.

Another scenario gives the existing $290,000 three additional years to grow. At 3% real for 27 years, it reaches about $644,174. That remains below $780,000. More importantly, retiring later could change pension income, spending and the withdrawal horizon, so the target must also be rebuilt.

Other scenarios might change recurring spending or retain some retirement earnings. Compare the lifestyle consequences as well as the totals. A projection that succeeds only after large spending cuts should display those cuts clearly.

Verify pensions and the withdrawal phase separately

A Coast FI calculation finishes at retirement; it does not show what happens afterward. The retirement phase needs its own timeline for taxes, pensions, inflation, market losses and longevity. A single target can conceal an expensive period before pension income begins.

Service Canada's CPP Statement of Contributions helps identify recorded earnings, contributions and benefit estimates. Check the assumptions behind the particular estimate being used. Reduced work can affect future pension income; carrying an old estimate into a new work plan without checking it is not a neutral choice. For QPP or an employer pension, obtain the corresponding record and estimate.

Also distinguish a household's income from an individual's income. Death, separation or disability may change both spending and benefits. A shared plan should not assume that every source continues unchanged for a survivor.

A short learning exercise and review record

Keep Mira's original $30,000 annual spending gap and 25-year accumulation period, but change the target-setting input from 4% to 3.5%. Leave the assumed accumulation return at 4% real after fees. What changes?

The retirement target becomes approximately $857,143, and the present Coast FI threshold becomes $321,529. The smaller withdrawal input raises the target; it does not reduce the investment growth assumption. Those two percentages do different jobs.

Finish each review with a dated note: inputs verified, assumptions retained, scenarios tested, unresolved questions and the next review trigger. Document a considered decision to make no change as carefully as a decision to act. The purpose is a coherent plan that can be examined, not a prediction made to look certain.

Evidence behind the explanation

Sources & checks

Linked sources were consulted on October 28, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.

  1. Retirement checklistFinancial Consumer Agency of Canada · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Inventory of retirement income, expenses and other planning considerations.

  2. 2026 Projection Assumption GuidelinesFP Canada and Institute of Financial Planning · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Long-term projection assumptions and sensitivity analysis; example return rates are separately labelled as illustrative.

  3. What is a TFSACanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-10-28

    General tax-free treatment of eligible TFSA income and withdrawals and the need for contribution room.

  4. CPP Statement of ContributionsService Canada · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Contribution and pensionable earnings records and benefit estimates, supporting verification of pension inputs.

When this article needs another review
  • New projection guidelines or material changes to retirement assumptions.
  • Changes to Canadian pension or TFSA rules referenced in the examples.
  • A numerical correction or a source revision that changes the explanation.

Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.

About this educational article

Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.

This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.

Read our editorial standards · Report a correction