Financial independence · Article 69

Real versus nominal returns in a Coast FI calculation

Keep purchasing power consistent in Coast FI calculations by separating nominal returns, inflation, investment fees and the tax treatment of each account.

Published by North of Numbers · · 6 min read

Educational purposes only. Examples are fictional and in Canadian dollars unless stated otherwise.

Start here

Should a Coast FI calculation use real or nominal returns?

Either method can work when every input uses consistent units. A target expressed in today’s purchasing power requires a real growth rate. A target expressed in future dollars requires a nominal rate and an inflation adjustment to the target. Fees and applicable taxes must also be accounted for without being deducted twice. The exact real return is the nominal growth factor divided by the inflation factor, minus one; simply subtracting rates is an approximation.

What you’ll learn

  • Use real growth with today’s dollars or nominal growth with inflated future dollars.
  • Account for fees and taxes once, in the appropriate part of the model.
  • A compound growth assumption is different from an arithmetic average of annual returns.

Identify the units before trusting the answer

A Coast FI calculator can produce a precise-looking number from inconsistent inputs. A common mismatch combines a retirement target measured in today's purchasing power with a growth rate that includes inflation. The model then treats rising prices as though they were an increase in real wealth. That can make the current amount required look much smaller than it should.

The remedy begins with labels. Put “today's Canadian dollars” or “future Canadian dollars” beside every target. Put “nominal” or “real” beside every return. Add whether the rate is before or after fees and applicable taxes. These labels are part of the calculation, not optional explanatory notes.

Distinguish a price change from a return

Nominal returns describe the change in the number of dollars. Real returns describe the change in what those dollars can buy after inflation. The Bank of Canada's Inflation Calculator uses CPI to compare purchasing power across dates. CPI represents a broad basket; a household's own expenses can rise at a different rate.

Suppose an account grows from $100 to $105 while the same basket of goods rises from $100 to $102. The account has 5% more dollars, but its purchasing power increases by approximately 2.94%. Divide 1.05 by 1.02, then subtract one. The difference from 3% is small for one year but can matter when compounded over decades.

This calculation describes consistent units. It does not say either inflation or returns will remain stable, or that a broad price index perfectly reflects future rent, travel or care costs. A planning model may need separate assumptions for expenses that do not follow general inflation.

Start with a clearly defined return

The 2026 Projection Assumption Guidelines, published in April 2026, identifies its return assumptions as nominal and before fees. It also distinguishes long-term projections from certainty about future markets. A reader should not take any published return number and insert it into a calculator without checking the definition.

For our fictional example, assume a constant 5% annual effective nominal return after investment fees. This is an invented teaching assumption, not a quoted forecast or an asset recommendation. Assume investments remain in a tax-sheltered retirement account during the growth period, with no additional contributions or withdrawals. Any later withdrawal taxes are outside this example's target calculation.

That last condition matters. CRA's Making RRSP withdrawals distinguishes growth retained inside an RRSP from generally taxable withdrawals. A gross retirement-account target should be compared with a gross starting balance. If the intended target is spendable after-tax wealth, the tax conversion needs to be included before drawing a conclusion about funding.

Calculate the same result two ways

Assume retirement is exactly twenty years away. The desired gross account balance is the future equivalent of $1,000,000 today. Annual inflation is assumed to be 2%, compounded annually. Both approaches below assume the same investment return, timing and tax treatment.

Using real dollars, the exact real rate is 1.05 ÷ 1.02 − 1, or approximately 2.941176%. The current amount required is $1,000,000 divided by that real growth factor over twenty years. The result is approximately $560,038.

Using nominal dollars, first inflate the target: $1,000,000 × 1.02^20 = approximately $1,485,947. Then discount that future-dollar target at the 5% nominal return: $1,485,947 ÷ 1.05^20 = approximately $560,038. Unrounded values produce the same answer.

MethodTarget at retirementGrowth usedRequired today
Real-dollar method$1,000,000 in today's purchasing power2.941176% real$560,038
Nominal-dollar method$1,485,947 in future dollars5% nominal$560,038
Inconsistent shortcut$1,000,000 treated as future dollars5% nominal$376,889

The inconsistent shortcut understates the required starting amount by about $183,148. It answers a different question: how to reach one million future dollars, which would buy less than one million dollars buys today. Rounding the two displayed thresholds before subtracting them can create a one-dollar difference.

Test a higher inflation assumption

Keep the 5% nominal return and twenty-year horizon, but increase annual inflation to 3%. The exact real return falls to 1.05 ÷ 1.03 − 1, approximately 1.941748%. The current amount needed for the same purchasing-power target rises to approximately $680,704.

The higher required amount is not caused by a smaller nominal account return. The number of dollars is growing at the same assumed pace; the cost of the target lifestyle is growing faster. That distinction helps explain why a portfolio can reach a large nominal balance while purchasing less than expected.

Do not automatically increase the nominal return whenever inflation increases. Some economic relationships may influence long-term expectations, but the model should make those assumptions explicit. Changing one input to cancel another would prevent the exercise from revealing the inflation risk being tested.

Avoid deducting the same cost twice

If a return is already after investment fees, subtracting another annual fee allowance understates projected growth. Conversely, using a before-fee return without a cost adjustment overstates it. Fees charged as a percentage of assets, fixed account charges and transaction costs may require different treatment in a detailed model.

Taxes also occur at different times. A non-registered account may incur annual tax on some investment income, while other tax may arise when gains are realized. An RRSP withdrawal may create tax later. A TFSA has different treatment again. A single blanket tax haircut can be a teaching simplification, but it should not be mistaken for an account-by-account forecast.

Use compounding rather than a simple average

Suppose an investment earns 20% in one year and loses 20% in the next. The arithmetic average is zero. Yet $100 becomes $120 and then $96, leaving a 4% cumulative loss. The compound annual return is approximately negative 2.02%, because the second return applies to a different balance.

A smooth Coast FI projection needs a compound rate, not merely the arithmetic average of a list of annual returns. Even a suitable compound assumption does not show volatility or the probability of reaching the target by a particular date. Those uncertainties require additional scenarios, and the drawdown period after retirement adds further questions.

A learning exercise with a cross-check

Take a desired real return of 3% and assumed inflation of 2%. The exactly matching nominal return is 1.03 × 1.02 − 1 = 5.06%, not 5%. Use that nominal rate with an inflated target, and use 3% with the target in today's dollars. The starting amounts should match.

If they do not, check the number of periods, whether deposits occur at the beginning or end of each period, and whether fees or taxes were treated differently. In a pure coasting model there are no deposits or withdrawals. That simple identity is a useful way to catch inconsistent units before building a more detailed retirement projection.

Evidence behind the explanation

Sources & checks

Linked sources were consulted on October 28, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.

  1. Inflation CalculatorBank of Canada · Accessed 2026-10-28

    CPI-based purchasing-power comparisons describe the price of a broad consumer basket.

  2. 2026 Projection Assumption GuidelinesFP Canada Standards Council and Institute of Financial Planning · Accessed 2026-10-28

    April 2026 guidance distinguishes nominal before-fee assumptions and calls for sensitivity analysis and review; no empirical withdrawal result quoted.

  3. Making RRSP withdrawalsCanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-10-28

    RRSP growth is generally sheltered while retained; withdrawals generally taxable and locked-in funds have restrictions.

When this article needs another review
  • Changes to inflation, investment-cost or tax assumptions.
  • Changes in the definitions or publication year of any return assumptions used.

Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.

About this educational article

Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.

This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.

Read our editorial standards · Report a correction