The account and what it holds are different things.
A TFSA generally does not provide a contribution deduction, while qualifying withdrawals are generally tax-free. RRSP contributions may be deductible within personal room, with withdrawals generally taxable. Those broad features do not determine which account a person should select.
An annual dollar limit is not the same as personal contribution room. Past activity, income, residency and pension adjustments can matter. Official records and a person’s own transaction records help establish the actual situation.
The account comparison tool explains deductions, withdrawals and cautions side by side. It does not rank accounts or calculate a personal tax strategy.
Worked example
Using invented tax assumptions, a $1,000 deductible contribution at a 30% marginal rate changes tax by $300. An assumed $1,000 taxable withdrawal at 20% leaves $800 after that tax. A fair comparison also states what happens to any earlier tax saving. These rates are not current brackets or a recommended strategy.
Have both contribution and withdrawal treatment been considered?
A deduction today and a taxable withdrawal later occur at different times. Comparing just one stage can obscure the other. Account rules are also distinct from investment performance: the same hypothetical growth arithmetic does not establish eligibility or personal room. The separate TFSA and RRSP guides explain these stages without ranking accounts.
North of Numbers provides financial education and educational tools only. Nothing on this website constitutes financial, investment, tax, legal, accounting, mortgage, insurance or other professional advice. Information and calculator results are general and illustrative in nature and may not apply to your individual circumstances. Hypothetical outcomes are not predictions or guarantees.
WORKED LEARNING PATH · CHECKED OCTOBER 22, 2026
TFSA versus RRSP: compare the full timeline
Use progressive 2026 tax brackets, separate room records and matching investment assumptions.
A deduction can cross several brackets. The tool removes income from the top down and shows each federal and provincial slice. For a 2026 Alberta illustration, moving taxable income from $65,000 to $55,000 produces a modelled $2,697.01 reduction under the included basic credits and rules. Multiplying the whole deduction by the original marginal rate would miss the crossed thresholds. The model is deliberately limited; it is not a complete return or a promised cash refund.
Keep three room amounts distinct
Available RRSP contribution room controls whether a new deposit fits. The remaining deduction limit controls what can be deducted now; a contribution can remain undeducted. TFSA room is separate and does not equal account value. The comparison assumes a new cash deposit and does not incorporate existing undeducted RRSP contributions. Use reconciled records rather than inferring limits from salary or a balance.
Put withdrawal room in the correct year
Start with $7,000 of available TFSA room on January 1, 2026, contribute $4,000 and withdraw $1,000. Current room is $3,000, not $4,000. The ordinary withdrawal adds back on January 1, 2027, making $4,000 before any new annual limit. The worksheet does not invent an unannounced 2027 limit. Growth and losses do not change contribution room; direct transfers and specified distributions have different treatment.
State what happens to the tax reduction
Use the same starting cash deposit, gross return, fee and horizon. Then choose whether the modelled tax reduction is reinvested and how long it takes to become available. A reduction may lower tax owing rather than produce a refund. Reinvestment in the separate TFSA requires room under that scenario. If it is spent, the comparison has equal starting deposits but different lifetime saving. A refund is not free extra money.
Compare spendable values and liquidity
The future RRSP withdrawal tax is an explicit assumed effective rate, separate from today’s bracket calculation. The TFSA result and the RRSP result after assumed tax are displayed year by year. Ordinary RRSP withdrawals are generally taxable and do not restore room; ordinary TFSA withdrawals generally do. Account choice and investment risk remain separate questions. No assumed return or withdrawal rate is a forecast.
Name the missing household effects
Benefits, income-tested credits, age and pension credits, spousal situations, loss carryforwards, foreign income, alternative minimum tax and exceptional transactions can materially change a real result. The model lists its included basic credits and exclusions. Change one assumption at a time; keep the assumptions with the exported PDF. A larger projected number does not determine personal suitability.
Version 2026-10-22.1. Retrieved October 22, 2026. Modelled future years hold current rules constant. Historical pension years are labelled separately. Download formulas, assumptions and test register.
RRSP contribution room and the deduction limit answer different questions. TFSA contribution room is not the account value. In the comparison, enter a new deposit with separately verified room and deduction limits, then use the same return, fee and horizon for both accounts. The current deduction effect follows progressive 2026 brackets for the selected province or territory. The future withdrawal tax is a separate assumption, not a forecast. Household benefits and other listed effects are outside this limited model.
For the default Ontario 2026 illustration, an $8,000 deduction from $80,000 taxable income produces a modelled $2,522 tax reduction, including the modelled Ontario health-premium change. This may lower tax owing rather than become a cash refund. Compare reinvesting it after one year with spending it. The latter has different lifetime saving even though the initial deposits match. Separately, $7,000 TFSA room minus $4,000 contributions leaves $3,000 this year; a $1,000 ordinary withdrawal restores room next January 1, not immediately.
An account’s tax rules do not determine the risk or cost of its holdings. Keep growth, fees, liquidity and uncertainty visible when comparing examples. Investing 101 is an existing optional course at $79 CAD, one time, with ongoing access while the website operates and no renewal fee. It offers Canadian account, investing, diversification, risk and fee lessons with guided practice, without stock tips or a personalized recommendation. Preview the course and confirm the current order total before buying. The free comparison and immediate PDF remain available.
Email delivery is not available here yet. Bookmark this page or open any session above.
Related calculators and guides
How a TFSA works in Canada — Separate the account’s tax rules from the money or investments held inside it.
How an RRSP works in Canada — Understand deductions, tax deferral and why an account balance is not the same as after-tax spending money.