Start here
How can I compare a temporary savings rate with an ordinary savings account?
Compare the interest earned on the same balance over the same dates, after any costs. A promotional rate is usually annualized, even when it applies for only a few months. Identify the eligible portion of your balance, when the promotion starts and ends, and the rate afterwards. Then model deposits and withdrawals on their actual dates. Keep account access, deposit protection and tax treatment separate from the rate comparison; a higher headline does not answer those questions.
What you’ll learn
- An annualized promotional rate is not the percentage your balance earns during a short offer period.
- Model the eligible balance and the post-promotion rate over the full period you need the account.
- Subtract actual costs, check access and protection, and record the date the comparison needs updating.
Translate the headline into a calendar
A savings promotion is easiest to understand as a temporary set of rules attached to money and dates. The useful question is how much interest those rules produce before the money is needed. Comparing two large percentages without matching their durations leaves that question unanswered.
FCAC explains that introductory savings rates last for a limited period and may fall afterwards. Interest is commonly calculated daily and paid monthly; the agreement determines the calculation and any balance tiers. FCAC savings-account guidance
Start a worksheet with the amount already saved, future contributions, expected withdrawals and the final comparison date. A holiday fund needed in four months and an emergency reserve held for a year have different timelines even if their opening balances match.
Identify which money qualifies
Ask whether eligibility depends on being a new customer, accepting an invitation, opening a particular account, adding new money or exceeding a reference balance. Record any maximum eligible amount. These are questions to answer from the actual offer, not assumptions to infer from an advertisement.
Tangerine’s published savings-offer terms illustrate account and customer restrictions, primary-holder requirements, balance caps and a defined promotional period. This is an example of how terms are structured, not a claim that a particular offer or rate is currently available to every reader. Tangerine savings-offer terms
For a fictional “new money” offer, suppose the relevant reference balance is $12,000 and the qualifying balance later becomes $20,000. If the contract defines eligible new money as the excess over that reference, only $8,000 receives the promotional treatment. Moving $12,000 between accounts would not automatically establish eligibility. The real definition could aggregate several accounts or exclude particular transfers.
Worked example: a higher headline, a lower annual result
Consider two fictional non-registered accounts holding a constant $20,000 for 365 days. Account A pays an annualized 4.5% for 120 days, followed by 1% for 245 days. Account B pays 2.5% throughout. These are invented rates, held constant solely for this illustration.
Assume simple daily interest using a 365-day divisor, no compounding, no deposits or withdrawals, full eligibility and no fees or tax in this first calculation. Actual monthly interest credits may themselves earn interest; that is deliberately excluded so the timing is visible.
| Component | Calculation | Interest |
|---|---|---|
| A: promotional period | $20,000 × 4.5% × 120 ÷ 365 | $295.89 |
| A: remaining period | $20,000 × 1% × 245 ÷ 365 | $134.25 |
| A: total year | Sum using unrounded amounts | $430.14 |
| B: full year | $20,000 × 2.5% | $500.00 |
Account B earns $69.86 more across the full year. Account A’s time-weighted simple annual rate is about 2.151%, calculated as (4.5% × 120 + 1% × 245) ÷ 365. That is a comparison statistic under these assumptions, not a promised effective annual yield.
The 4.5% headline does not mean earning $900 during the 120-day promotion. It describes an annualized rate applied for only part of a year.
Change the horizon before declaring a winner
Across just the first 120 days, Account B earns $164.38, while A earns $295.89. A is ahead by $131.51. The conclusion changes because the question changes: a four-month comparison excludes A’s later low-rate period.
An intention to move the money again is another scenario, not an established future rate. Label the replacement rate and the transfer date as assumptions. Include a fallback where no suitable promotion appears or the transfer happens later than expected.
If the balance will fall to pay a bill, split the calculation at that withdrawal. Applying the opening balance to every day overstates the interest. Similarly, money added near the end should not receive a full promotional period in the model unless the actual terms give each deposit its own clock.
Separate the base rate from the promotional uplift
Some offers describe a total promotional rate; others describe a bonus added to a regular rate. Treating a total as an additional bonus would count the base rate twice.
Return to the fictional $12,000 reference balance and $20,000 total balance. Assume the first $12,000 earns 1% while the eligible $8,000 earns a total annualized 4.5%, all for 120 days under the same simple-interest convention. Interest is $39.45 + $118.36 = $157.81. Paying 4.5% on the whole $20,000 would instead produce $295.89, overstating this offer’s result by $138.08.
If the offer describes 1% regular interest plus 3.5% bonus interest on eligible money, the same calculation can be written as 1% on $20,000 plus an additional 3.5% on $8,000. Both methods produce $157.81. Use one method consistently.
Deduct costs and distinguish earning from access
Transaction and transfer fees can apply even where there is no monthly savings-account fee. Transfer times also depend on the institution and account. FCAC account costs and access
Suppose obtaining the first example’s 120-day promotional advantage requires $25 in actual costs that the comparison account does not incur. The advantage falls from $131.51 to $106.51, before tax. Do not add a fee simply because one could exist; use the applicable schedule and the transactions the scenario actually requires.
Record when funds must be usable, not merely when a transfer can be requested. A bill due on a particular morning needs accessible money by then. Interest accrual, a deposit hold and an outgoing-transfer deadline are separate items to confirm.
Keep any cash welcome bonus in a separate row until its conditions and payment timing are established. Otherwise a conditional reward can make a modest interest comparison appear much larger than it is.
Keep taxes and deposit protection visible
For ordinary taxable interest, CRA requires reporting even when a small amount produces no T5 slip. A tax slip is a reporting document, not the condition that makes interest taxable. CRA interest-income reporting
For a simplified sensitivity test, assume both accounts’ interest is taxable at a constant 30% marginal rate with no benefit interactions. Their $69.86 gross difference becomes approximately $48.90 after tax. This assumption does not determine someone’s actual rate or the tax treatment of an unrelated promotional bonus.
Deposit coverage answers a different question. CDIC insures eligible deposits at member institutions within its coverage categories, up to $100,000 per category including principal and interest; coverage is not a separate allowance for every account nickname. CDIC coverage rules
Check the actual legal institution and deposit category. Provincial credit-union protection requires its own review. A rate promotion is not evidence of coverage, and a registered-account label does not settle transfer or contribution rules.
Build a review note that survives the advertisement
Save the offer terms, enrollment confirmation, opening balance and end date. Record the regular rate assumed after expiry and where to verify it. The note should allow someone to reproduce the comparison without relying on a banner that may disappear.
At review time, compare actual interest with the worksheet. Differences may come from posting dates, changing balances, compounding or eligibility. Investigate the reason before treating a small discrepancy as an error.
Learning exercise: a deposit arrives halfway through
A fictional account pays an annualized 4% for 90 days. You hold $10,000 for all 90 days and add $5,000 with exactly 45 qualifying interest days remaining. Assume simple interest, a 365-day divisor, no fees and no compounding. How much interest is earned?
The answer is $123.29: $10,000 × 4% × 90 ÷ 365 plus $5,000 × 4% × 45 ÷ 365. Assuming the full $15,000 earned for all 90 days would produce $147.95, an overstatement of $24.66. The exercise’s main lesson is practical: follow each amount for the days it actually qualifies.
Evidence behind the explanation
Sources & checks
Linked sources were consulted on November 1, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.
- Savings accountsFinancial Consumer Agency of Canada · Accessed 2026-11-01
Limited promotional periods, daily calculations and monthly payments, balance tiers, transaction fees and transfer timing.
- New bank account offers and bank promotionsTangerine · Accessed 2026-11-01
Issuer-specific illustration of account/customer eligibility, primary-holder restrictions, balance caps and defined offer periods; no current offered rate is asserted.
- Line 12100 – Interest and other investment incomeCanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-11-01
Reporting taxable interest even when no T5 slip is issued for small amounts.
- What’s coveredCanada Deposit Insurance Corporation · Accessed 2026-11-01
Eligible deposits, member-institution coverage and separate categories with principal and interest included in the limit.
When this article needs another review
- Changes to the terms, eligibility, base rates, promotional periods or fees of any offer used in a future comparison.
- Changes to deposit-insurance categories, coverage limits or taxable-interest reporting rules.
- Replacing any hypothetical rate or date requires recalculating the full comparison, including compounding and actual cash movements.
Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.
About this educational article
Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.
This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.