Debt and credit · Article 144

Leasing versus buying a car in Canada: compare the same years and the value left over

Compare leasing and buying a vehicle using taxes, total payments, remaining loan debt, resale value and kilometre charges over the same period of time.

Published by North of Numbers · · 7 min read

Educational purposes only. Examples are fictional and in Canadian dollars unless stated otherwise.

Start here

How can I compare a car lease with a purchase loan when their payments and terms differ?

Choose one comparison date and add each option’s cash payments through that date. For a purchase, also include the loan balance still owing and subtract the vehicle’s realistic net resale value. For a lease return, include contractual end charges and no owned vehicle. Model a lease buyout separately, including taxes and financing if needed. Use the same vehicle, driving distance and operating assumptions. A smaller monthly payment alone does not establish the lower cost over the chosen years.

What you’ll learn

  • Use the same comparison period, and include both unpaid loan debt and the vehicle’s remaining value.
  • Separate returning a leased vehicle from buying it; the residual is not automatically an all-in purchase price.
  • Test kilometres, resale value and fees because plausible changes can reverse the comparison.

Choose an end date before comparing payments

A forty-eight-month lease and a sixty-month loan can both fund four years of driving, but they leave different obligations and assets at the end. Comparing only the monthly payments misses that difference. Comparing all sixty loan payments with only forty-eight lease payments answers mismatched questions.

Ontario's vehicle-sales regulator, OMVIC, encourages consumers to examine the selling price and borrowing cost alongside the payment. A low instalment can be the result of extending the debt. OMVIC car-loan guidance

Start with a chosen date, such as the end of month forty-eight. Record what has been paid, what remains owing and what property the household owns then. This creates a comparison that can be checked without declaring leasing or buying universally better.

Identify what the lease actually promises

OMVIC distinguishes closed-end leases, which generally offer a return or purchase option, from open-end arrangements where a residual-value shortfall can remain the customer's responsibility. Excess kilometres, damage and wear can also create charges under the agreement. OMVIC leasing guidance

Record the amount due initially, every scheduled payment, any refundable deposit, kilometre allowance, excess-distance rate, return charges and purchase-option terms. Do not count a refundable deposit as a permanent expense unless the scenario assumes it is retained; still show when that cash becomes unavailable.

The following example uses a fictional closed-end lease with clearly specified return terms. It does not describe an offer currently available from a manufacturer or lender.

Put taxes in the correct rows

CRA explains that GST/HST generally applies to vehicle purchases from registered businesses and to lease payments. For leases exceeding three months, the vehicle's required province of registration generally determines the GST/HST rate on payments. CRA vehicle-tax guidance

The example assumes an ordinary personal vehicle purchased, delivered and registered in Ontario, with no trade-in, exemption or rebate. Ontario's HST rate is 13% as checked for this article. CRA GST/HST rates

Use actual local rules for another province or transaction. A private sale, business use or a trade-in introduces different considerations. The example's tax calculation cannot be copied into those situations without review.

Worked example: four years with the same vehicle

Assume the purchase price is $40,000 before HST, with all dealer charges included. The entire $45,200 after-tax amount is financed for sixty months at a fictional nominal annual rate of 6%, calculated monthly. There is no down payment, balloon or early-repayment charge. Payments occur at month-end.

The alternative lease quotes $450 before HST for each of forty-eight payments, no additional initial payment and a $300 return charge already including any applicable tax. Assume no excess kilometres or damage. The purchase vehicle's net sale proceeds at month forty-eight are estimated at $22,000 after selling costs.

Both options have the same assumed operating costs, excluded from this narrow comparison. There is no discounting or investment return credited to differences in payment timing.

Through month 48Purchase loanLease and return
Monthly payment, including relevant tax$873.84$508.50
Forty-eight payments$41,944.45$24,408.00
Debt to settle at comparison date$10,153.12$0.00
Additional return charge$0.00$300.00
Subtract net vehicle sale proceeds−$22,000.00$0.00
Net cost over four years$30,097.56$24,708.00

Loan figures use the unrounded monthly payment internally; displayed amounts may not add exactly because of cent rounding. The standard amortization calculation uses $45,200 × (6% ÷ 12) ÷ [1 − (1 + 6% ÷ 12) raised to −60].

Under these invented terms, returning the lease costs $5,389.56 less over four years. This result depends on the lease quotation and estimated sale proceeds, rather than following automatically from either financing method.

Understand the debt and value adjustment

The purchase column adds the remaining loan balance because the comparison ends before the debt does. It subtracts sale proceeds because the buyer owns an asset that the returning lessee does not.

This is equivalent to subtracting the buyer's remaining equity from payments already made. Here estimated equity is about $11,846.88: the $22,000 vehicle value less $10,153.12 owed. Ignoring the vehicle understates what buying leaves behind; ignoring the debt overstates it.

A borrower who keeps the vehicle rather than selling still has that estimated asset and liability. The adjustment makes the four-year positions comparable; it does not instruct the household to sell. A real sale also needs a payout statement and a realistic estimate of net proceeds.

Test the resale estimate instead of treating it as certain

If the purchased car is worth $28,000 net at month forty-eight, its four-year cost falls to $24,097.56, which is $610.44 below the lease-return scenario. If it is worth $18,000, the purchase cost rises to $34,097.56.

The break-even net resale value is about $27,389.56: payments made plus debt remaining, minus the $24,708 lease-return cost. This is a threshold within the example, not a forecast of the used-car market.

The lease's contractual residual or buyout figure is not independent evidence of future market value. Use separate rows for the amount the contract demands and the amount a buyer might actually pay for the vehicle. Combining them removes a major uncertainty from view without resolving it.

Add kilometres and operating differences explicitly

Suppose the lease allows 80,000 kilometres over four years, but expected driving totals 96,000. At an invented $0.18 for each excess kilometre, the charge is $2,880 before tax. Assuming 13% HST applies, it becomes $3,254.40, raising lease-return cost to $27,962.40.

Higher mileage could also lower the purchased vehicle's resale value. Update both sides when the driving assumption changes. Applying a lease penalty while retaining an unrealistically low-mileage resale estimate for the purchase would bias the comparison.

Check insurance quotes, required maintenance and foreseeable repairs separately. OMVIC notes that a lessee remains responsible for expenses such as maintenance, repairs, licensing and insurance. OMVIC lease responsibilities

Equal operating costs were a simplifying assumption, not a guarantee. Record only differences supported by the vehicles, contracts and quotations being compared.

Treat buying out the lease as another scenario

Assume the same lease permits a $22,000 purchase at its end, plus 13% HST, with no purchase fee. The $300 return charge applies only when returning the vehicle and is excluded here. Paying the buyout in cash requires $24,860 at month forty-eight.

Total cash paid becomes $24,408 + $24,860 = $49,268. Subtracting the assumed $22,000 vehicle value gives a four-year net cost of $27,268. Buying out is neither the $24,708 return scenario nor merely an additional $22,000 payment.

If the buyout must be financed, add that new loan's terms to the next period. Having a contractual purchase option does not establish that financing will be approved or that the future rate will resemble today's quote.

Extend both alternatives when the real horizon is longer

For an eight-year question, carry the purchased vehicle's remaining payments and later repair estimates forward. Give the leasing route an explicit second vehicle, replacement lease or buyout scenario. Then subtract any assets still owned and include debts still outstanding at year eight.

Do not assume the current lease quotation will repeat four years later. Present that as one scenario and vary it. A four-year comparison can be useful without pretending to settle an eight-year ownership decision.

Learning exercise: three years and a remaining loan

A fictional lease requires $1,500 initially, thirty-six payments of $420 and a $300 return charge. All amounts already include taxes. Buying requires $5,000 initially and thirty-six payments of $450, leaving $9,000 owing. Estimated net sale proceeds are $16,000. Assume equal operating costs and no other charges.

The lease costs $16,920. The purchase costs $5,000 + $16,200 + $9,000 − $16,000 = $14,200, or $2,720 less. If net sale proceeds fall to $13,000, purchase cost becomes $17,200, which is $280 more than leasing. A comparison becomes more useful when it shows which uncertain number could change the result.

Evidence behind the explanation

Sources & checks

Linked sources were consulted on November 2, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.

  1. Car LoansOntario Motor Vehicle Industry Council · Accessed 2026-11-02

    Compare selling price, instalments and borrowing costs rather than treating a low payment as a complete comparison.

  2. LeasingOntario Motor Vehicle Industry Council · Accessed 2026-11-02

    Closed-end versus open-end arrangements, residual shortfalls, kilometre and wear charges, and lessee operating responsibilities.

  3. GST/HST and motor vehiclesCanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-11-02

    Tax on registered-business vehicle sales and leases, with registration-based rate rules for leases over three months.

  4. GST/HST calculator (and rates)Canada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-11-02

    Ontario’s 13% HST rate and the importance of transaction-specific tax treatment.

When this article needs another review
  • Changes to sales-tax rates, provincial vehicle transaction rules or applicable exemptions.
  • A new quote, trade-in, loan payout amount, kilometre estimate, fee or buyout term requires recalculation.
  • Update resale and operating-cost estimates when the vehicle, condition, ownership horizon or driving assumptions change.

Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.

About this educational article

Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.

This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.

Read our editorial standards · Report a correction