Withdrawal strategies · Article 51

The 4% rule explained: initial withdrawal and inflation adjustments

Understand how the 4% rule sets the first withdrawal, adjusts later amounts for inflation, and differs from spending 4% of the current portfolio.

Published by North of Numbers · · 6 min read

Educational purposes only. Examples are fictional and in Canadian dollars unless stated otherwise.

Start here

Does the 4% rule mean taking 4% of the portfolio every year?

The traditional method takes a percentage of the opening portfolio once, then adjusts that dollar withdrawal for inflation in later years. It does not normally recalculate 4% of the current balance each year. Its historical research context also matters: a particular portfolio, spending pattern and retirement horizon were tested. A Canadian household still needs to account for taxes, fees, pension income and changing expenses before translating a portfolio withdrawal into usable spending money.

What you’ll learn

  • The initial percentage and later current withdrawal ratios are different measures.
  • Inflation adjustments maintain assumed purchasing power; they are not additional real income.
  • A historical withdrawal result does not guarantee Canadian after-tax retirement spending.

The percentage sets a starting amount

The traditional 4% approach starts with the portfolio value at retirement. Four percent of that opening value becomes the first year's withdrawal. Later withdrawals usually follow changes in prices, rather than being recalculated as 4% of whatever the investments are then worth.

That distinction changes the household experience. A falling portfolio does not automatically reduce the next withdrawal under this method. A rising portfolio does not automatically produce a raise beyond the inflation adjustment. The arrangement aims for relatively stable purchasing power while leaving the portfolio to absorb changes in markets.

The word rule can sound more authoritative than the evidence warrants. It describes a spending method and a historical research finding. It is not an insurance contract, a Canadian tax rule, or a promise that every retirement can be financed this way.

Understand the original evidence before borrowing the number

William Bengen's October 1994 paper tested retirement withdrawals against US investment returns and inflation from Ibbotson data beginning in 1926. His initial illustration rebalanced US common stocks and intermediate-term Treasury bonds equally, then explored other allocations. The familiar result concerned an initial 4% withdrawal followed by inflation adjustments, with the tested portfolios lasting at least about 30 years. The analysis assumed tax-deferred assets; it was not a Canadian after-tax income calculation or a personalized fee model. Bengen's original paper

A historical stress test answers what happened under its data and assumptions. It cannot establish that the next difficult period will resemble the worst period already observed. The useful lesson is the discipline of specifying a withdrawal schedule and testing adverse conditions, rather than treating a rounded number as a universal entitlement.

Fictional CAD example: follow the dollars for three years

Assume a retiree begins with $800,000. Withdrawals occur at the start of each year. Returns apply afterward to the remaining investments and already reflect investment fees. Taxes are excluded, so withdrawals are gross amounts available before any personal tax. No contributions, outside income or extraordinary expenses enter this illustration.

The initial withdrawal is $800,000 × 4% = $32,000. Assume first-year inflation is 3%, second-year inflation is 2%, and investment returns are negative 10% in year one and positive 8% in year two. These are teaching assumptions, not forecasts.

StepCalculationResult
Year-one withdrawal$800,000 × 4%$32,000
End of year one($800,000 − $32,000) × 0.90$691,200
Year-two withdrawal$32,000 × 1.03$32,960
End of year two($691,200 − $32,960) × 1.08$710,899.20
Year-three withdrawal$32,960 × 1.02$33,619.20

The third withdrawal is not 4% of $710,899.20. It follows the inflation-adjusted spending schedule. Its current withdrawal ratio is approximately 4.73%, even though the initial rate was 4%.

Bengen's own explanation makes this first-year-versus-later-years distinction explicit. The author's explanation of the method

Keep the initial rate and current ratio separate

The initial rate compares the first withdrawal with the original portfolio. The current ratio compares a later withdrawal with the portfolio available at that later date. Both can be useful, but they answer different questions.

In year two, the example's $32,960 withdrawal represents approximately 4.77% of $691,200. That higher ratio signals increased demand on the remaining capital. It does not mean the retiree quietly changed the original rule to 4.77%.

Conversely, suppose the portfolio had grown to $1 million before that same $32,960 withdrawal. Its current ratio would be 3.296%. The planned amount would remain unchanged unless the spending policy itself changed. Market gains create options; the basic formula does not decide how to use them.

A review can therefore show both figures without turning either into an automatic instruction. It can also record the remaining time horizon, upcoming pension income and actual spending needs, which a single ratio cannot describe.

An inflation adjustment preserves a budget, not every purchase

A 3% increase means multiplying the previous amount by 1.03. It does not mean adding three percentage points to the withdrawal rate. Moving a 4% rate to 7% would be a much larger change.

Nor does an inflation adjustment create a discretionary raise in real purchasing power. In the example, $32,960 divided by 1.03 equals the original $32,000. The extra dollars merely compensate for the assumed price increase.

Household costs may not follow the chosen index exactly. A rent renewal, a new accessibility need or a major repair can differ substantially from average price changes. Those changes belong in a separate spending assessment. Hiding them inside an inflation assumption makes the source of pressure harder to identify.

Change one assumption: a larger early price increase

Keep the first-year investment loss unchanged, but make first-year inflation 6% instead of 3%. The second withdrawal becomes $32,000 × 1.06 = $33,920, which is $960 more than before.

After the same 8% second-year return, the portfolio becomes ($691,200 − $33,920) × 1.08 = $709,862.40. If second-year inflation remains 2%, the third withdrawal becomes $34,598.40.

The effect persists because future adjustments build on the higher spending base. Inflation is therefore more than a temporary inconvenience in a fixed-real withdrawal model. It can permanently increase the nominal cash the investments must supply.

This two-year comparison does not estimate a probability of failure. It identifies a mechanism that a longer retirement model must test.

Gross withdrawals are not the household's spending allowance

A $32,000 portfolio withdrawal may include money needed for tax. Ordinary RRSP withdrawals are taxable, and withholding may differ from the final tax calculated on the return. CRA: tax on RRSP withdrawals

For a purely arithmetic illustration, an assumed 20% effective tax on that withdrawal would leave $25,600. That is not an estimate of any reader's actual rate. Different account types, other income and provincial circumstances can change the outcome.

Investment distributions also need consistent counting. If $12,000 of cash distributions helps fund a $32,000 total withdrawal, those distributions are part of the $32,000. Treating them as an additional spending allowance would increase the total removal from the portfolio.

A short exercise that checks the meaning

Start with a fictional $500,000 portfolio and a 4% initial rate. Assume withdrawals occur at each year's start, first-year inflation is 2.5%, and the portfolio is worth $450,000 immediately before the second withdrawal. Ignore tax and fees for this exercise.

The first withdrawal is $20,000. The second is $20,500. Its current ratio is approximately 4.56%, while the original rate remains 4%. Recalculating 4% of $450,000 would instead produce $18,000: a different spending method.

A useful worksheet labels the original balance, withdrawal dates, inflation convention, taxes, costs and review conditions. Getting those labels right is the first step toward understanding what a withdrawal study can—and cannot—say about retirement income.

Evidence behind the explanation

Sources & checks

Linked sources were consulted on October 28, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.

  1. Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data (October 1994)William P. Bengen, Journal of Financial Planning · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Original US historical methodology, initial 50/50 allocation, inflation-adjusted withdrawals, portfolio longevity and tax-deferred scope.

  2. The 4% RuleWilliam P. Bengen · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Author clarification that the initial percentage is replaced by annual cost-of-living adjustments.

  3. Tax rates on withdrawalsCanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Ordinary RRSP withdrawal taxation and withholding versus final tax.

When this article needs another review
  • New original withdrawal research changes the historical-method description.
  • CRA changes ordinary RRSP withdrawal treatment.
  • An example assumption or withdrawal timing is revised.

Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.

About this educational article

Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.

This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.

Read our editorial standards · Report a correction