Withdrawal strategies · Article 55

Fixed real spending versus a fixed percentage of the current portfolio

Compare two withdrawal methods that begin at the same rate but produce different spending, purchasing power and portfolio balances after market changes.

Published by North of Numbers · · 6 min read

Educational purposes only. Examples are fictional and in Canadian dollars unless stated otherwise.

Start here

How does fixed real spending differ from taking a fixed percentage of the current portfolio?

Fixed real spending adjusts a starting dollar withdrawal for inflation, while a fixed-percentage method recalculates the payment from the current portfolio. The first stabilizes purchasing power but may strain the account after losses. The second reduces withdrawals when capital falls, preserving more assets by requiring lower spending. Avoiding an exact zero balance does not guarantee adequate income. A fair comparison examines essential expenses, the depth and duration of spending cuts, and any floor that changes the pure rule.

What you’ll learn

  • Identical first-year rates can produce very different later incomes.
  • A larger remaining portfolio may simply reflect less money withdrawn.
  • A percentage rule can preserve a positive account while failing to fund essentials.

Similar names can produce different incomes

A fixed-real withdrawal aims to maintain a specified level of purchasing power. It begins with a dollar amount and adjusts that amount for inflation. A fixed-percentage withdrawal takes the same fraction of the current portfolio each year, allowing the dollars received to rise or fall with the account.

Both can begin with 4% of the same opening balance. After that first payment, they can diverge sharply. One anchors the budget to prices; the other anchors it to available investment capital.

Bengen's explanation of the traditional method describes the first approach: the original percentage establishes the initial dollar withdrawal, followed by cost-of-living adjustments. The author's explanation

Choosing a label without understanding that distinction can create a serious mismatch between the modeled retirement and the spending a household expects to maintain.

Write the two rules before entering returns

For a fixed-real policy, the next withdrawal is the previous withdrawal multiplied by one plus the chosen inflation rate. It is a promise about the amount requested, not a guarantee that the portfolio can provide it indefinitely.

For a fixed-percentage policy, the next withdrawal is the chosen percentage multiplied by the portfolio balance measured at the specified review date. There is no separate inflation increase unless the policy explicitly adds one, which would create a different rule.

Bengen's December 2025 research note uses the fixed-percentage label for withdrawals recalculated from each year's opening portfolio. This article uses that definition without importing the paper's rate-selection results. Bengen: fixed-percentage withdrawals

The measurement date matters. Four percent of a balance before a large withdrawal is different from four percent afterward. A reproducible policy specifies the date, what assets count and whether the cash reserved for the coming payment is included.

Fictional CAD example: one opening balance, two paths

Assume $600,000 at retirement and a 4% first-year withdrawal under both policies. Withdrawals occur at each year's start. Returns apply afterward and are nominal returns after investment fees. Personal taxes are ignored. There are no contributions, other withdrawals or outside income.

Assume the portfolio loses 15% in year one and gains 10% in year two. Inflation is 3% in each year. These are invented assumptions chosen to demonstrate the mechanics.

Both policies first withdraw $24,000. The common end-of-year-one balance is ($600,000 − $24,000) × 0.85 = $489,600.

ItemFixed realFixed percentage
Year-one withdrawal$24,000$24,000
Year-two withdrawal$24,720$19,584
End of year two$511,368$517,017.60
Year-three withdrawal$25,461.60$20,680.70

The fixed-real year-two amount is $24,000 × 1.03. Its closing balance is ($489,600 − $24,720) × 1.10. The fixed-percentage amount is $489,600 × 4%, producing a closing balance of ($489,600 − $19,584) × 1.10.

The fixed-percentage portfolio finishes year two with more money because the retiree took less money out. That is a tradeoff between spending and retained capital, not evidence of a superior investment return.

Compare purchasing power as well as account balances

The fixed-percentage year-two withdrawal falls by 18.4% from $24,000 to $19,584. The reduction is larger than the 15% investment loss because the opening withdrawal also reduced the portfolio before that loss occurred.

With 3% inflation, the $19,584 payment has only about $19,014 of first-year purchasing power: $19,584 ÷ 1.03. Relative to the original $24,000 budget, that is roughly a 20.8% real reduction.

The fixed-real policy pays $24,720, which has exactly $24,000 of purchasing power under the assumed price increase. Its stability for the household requires a larger removal from the depressed portfolio.

Inflation measures changes in purchasing power, so nominal account values alone cannot settle which income path meets a budget. Bank of Canada: understanding inflation

Why avoiding exact depletion is an incomplete goal

A pure fixed-percentage rule removes only part of a positive balance. If returns never destroy the entire remaining portfolio, there are no other withdrawals or fixed charges, and the percentage is below 100%, some positive amount remains mathematically.

That property does not ensure useful income. Four percent of $100,000 is $4,000; four percent of $10,000 is $400. A policy can avoid literal zero while failing to meet basic expenses years earlier.

The relevant questions therefore include the lowest real withdrawal, how long reductions persist and whether outside income covers essential costs. Describing the method as unable to run out of money, without those qualifications, mistakes account survival for household security.

Real accounts also have practical constraints. Minimum transaction sizes, fixed fees, mandatory registered-account withdrawals and irregular expenses may break the assumptions of the pure mathematical example. Those details belong in an implementation model.

Change one assumption: essential spending is less flexible

Suppose the household's original $24,000 portfolio-funded budget includes $18,000 of essential expenses. After 3% inflation, those essentials require $18,540 in year two. The example's fixed-percentage withdrawal of $19,584 covers them with $1,044 remaining for other spending.

Now change only the portfolio balance at that review date to $400,000. Four percent supplies $16,000, which falls $2,540 short of the same essential budget. A willingness to cancel discretionary spending no longer solves the problem.

The fixed-real policy would still request $24,720. It would cover that year's budget if the withdrawal could be made, but would place greater pressure on the smaller portfolio. Neither formula eliminates the tension between current needs and future resources.

A spending floor can prevent income from falling below a chosen amount, but adding that floor turns the pure percentage rule into a hybrid. Its sustainability must be evaluated under the new rule.

Fixed nominal dollars are a third method

A household might instead withdraw $24,000 every year without inflation adjustments. That is neither of the two policies above. It smooths the number of dollars received while allowing purchasing power to decline when prices rise.

In the example, a fixed nominal payment in year three would still be $24,000, compared with $25,461.60 needed to match two years of 3% inflation. Its lower demand on the portfolio comes with a reduced real budget.

This distinction prevents an unfair comparison. A method that funds fewer goods and services can appear more sustainable simply because it is promising less. Tables of success rates need to say what spending standard each policy is expected to maintain.

A learning exercise that exposes the tradeoff

Take a fictional $750,000 portfolio and a 4% initial payment. Suppose the balance before year two is $675,000 and inflation is 2%. Ignore tax and use annual beginning-of-year withdrawals.

The fixed-real payment is $30,600; the fixed-percentage payment is $27,000. The $3,600 difference remains invested only because it is not spent. Compare each amount with an essential budget and identify which expenses would change.

A useful policy description ends with dates, dollar consequences and review conditions. The percentage is only one part of that description; the household's ability to live with the resulting payment path is another.

Evidence behind the explanation

Sources & checks

Linked sources were consulted on October 28, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.

  1. The 4% RuleWilliam P. Bengen · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Initial percentage followed by inflation adjustments.

  2. Research Report 4: Revisiting the Fixed Percentage Withdrawal Scheme (December 1, 2025)William P. Bengen · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Definition of annual fixed-percentage withdrawals and spending variability; no empirical rate imported.

  3. Understanding inflationBank of Canada · Accessed 2026-10-28

    Inflation and purchasing power distinction.

When this article needs another review
  • A cited author changes the method definitions.
  • The policy example gains a spending floor or other constraint.
  • New research is added with different success criteria.

Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.

About this educational article

Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.

This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.

Read our editorial standards · Report a correction