DOCUMENT WORKSHOP 1 OF 3
Fund documents: from the disclosure to the order confirmation
Compare mandates and total costs; distinguish an ETF quote, a market order and a limit order.
Read the method
Start with the exact fund and series, publication date, mandate, holdings and risk disclosure. Fund Facts summarizes a mutual fund; ETF Facts adds exchange-trading information. A risk rating is not a guarantee, a personal suitability score or a maximum possible loss. The prospectus and current holdings provide detail that these summaries omit.
Separate MER, trading expenses and any additional advice, account, currency or transaction charges. The management fee is a component of MER, so adding it again can double count. Published returns may already deduct fund expenses. A cost comparison is meaningful only after checking what is included and whether exposures and services are comparable.
The bid is a current buying quote and the ask a current selling quote. A market buy can fill at more than one ask as available units are used; a displayed last price is not a guaranteed execution price. A buy limit caps the execution price but may leave some or all units unfilled. Confirm quantity, price, commissions and settlement on the execution record before treating an intention as a holding.
The case and its assumptions
All fund names, mandates, ratings and quotes are invented. These extracts are teaching records, not complete regulatory forms or recommended products. Fund A is a global equity mutual fund; Fund B is a single-sector ETF. Both are quoted in CAD but may have foreign economic exposure. Annual fee arithmetic assumes a constant $20,000 base. The separate order exercise uses 100 ETF units and the displayed available ask quantities, with no quote changes or other buyers.
Invented Fund Facts extract: A, Series F
- Document date / mandate
- October 1, 2026 / global equities
- Top-ten weight / risk rating
- 24% / medium; no guarantee
- Fund expenses
- MER 0.60%; TER 0.05%; management fee already inside MER
- Advice
- Separate 1.00% annual charge; not included in MER
- Illustration
- Constant $20,000 for one year; no transaction charges assumed
Invented ETF Facts extract: B
- Document date / mandate
- October 1, 2026 / one industry
- Top-ten weight / risk rating
- 72% / high; no guarantee
- Fund expenses
- MER 0.20%; TER 0.10%; management fee already inside MER
- Other charges
- Same separate 1.00% advice assumption; two $10 trades in the annual fee illustration
- Published fund return convention
- Already net of fund expenses; excludes separate advice and brokerage charges
Separate exchange quote and order record
- Best bid / ask
- $24.90 / $25.10
- Available asks
- 40 units at $25.10; at least 60 more at $25.20
- Market-buy illustration
- 100 units; $10.00 total commission
- Alternative limit
- 100 units, maximum $25.05 each
- Round-trip illustration
- Separate assumption: 100 units can be bought at $25.10 and immediately sold at $24.90; $10 commission each way
Your tasks
Identify two reasons A and B are not interchangeable despite both holding equities. Find the evidence you would inspect beyond the extracts.
Calculate each annual cost illustration, including separate advice and the stated trades. Explain why a lower amount does not identify the suitable fund.
Calculate the 100-unit market-buy cash requirement using both ask levels and commission. What can the $25.05 limit order buy from these unchanged asks?
Calculate the separate round-trip spread cost and combined spread/commission cost. Explain why this is not a forecast of an annual cost or a claim that quotes remain fixed.
Show the calculation, the evidence that supports it and the fact that remains unknown. A matching number alone is not a complete explanation.
Compare your work with the reconciliation
- Read exposure before price
- A has global-equity exposure and a 24% top-ten weight; B is a single industry with 72% in its top ten. Inspect full holdings, benchmark, currency exposure, risk definitions, exact series, distribution policy and prospectus. Equal account currency does not establish equal underlying currency risk.
- A: annual illustrative cost: $330.00
- $20,000 × (0.60% + 0.05% + 1.00%) = $330. Do not add the management fee again.
- B: annual illustrative cost before spreads: $280.00
- $20,000 × (0.20% + 0.10% + 1.00%) + 2 × $10 = $280. The $50 difference excludes bid–ask spreads and other omitted charges; the mandates are different.
- Cash for the market-buy illustration: $2,526.00
- 40 × $25.10 + 60 × $25.20 + $10 = $2,526. Using $25.10 for all 100 units would omit available-depth constraints.
- Units available to the $25.05 limit at these asks: 0 units
- Both asks exceed the limit. No fill follows from this snapshot; a later fill is uncertain. A limit is a price condition, not an execution promise.
- Separate round-trip spread cost: $20.00
- 100 × ($25.10 − $24.90) = $20 before commissions, under the separate sufficient-depth assumption.
- Round-trip spread plus commissions: $40.00
- $20 spread + $10 buy commission + $10 sell commission = $40. This is a separate execution example, not an extra cost automatically added to every annual projection.
Compare two explanations
Incomplete reasoning: B is better because its MER is lower, and the market order will buy all 100 units at the displayed $25.10.
Why it falls short: It ignores concentration and other costs, then treats a quote with only 40 units available as an unlimited price guarantee.
Stronger reasoning: B’s stated annual cost is $280 versus $330 for A, before spreads, but its single-sector mandate and 72% top-ten weight make this an unequal-risk comparison. The order needs $2,526 under the supplied depth. I would verify the exact series, complete costs and execution instructions before drawing a conclusion.
Why it works: It reconciles cost and execution separately, cites the concentration evidence and names what remains unresolved.
Self-review
- Compare exact mandates and included costs, not names or MER alone.
- Use displayed quantities and distinguish price control from a fill guarantee.
- Keep the annual fee model separate from the execution scenarios.
For each criterion, mark your notes “explained”, “partly explained” or “revisit”. Compare the reasoning, then retry the missing step with the answer closed. This self-review does not certify a real decision or change your course completion.
Change the evidence
Only 30 units remain at $25.10; 70 are available at $25.30. Recompute a 100-unit market buy with the same commission. Under a buy limit of $25.10, what is the most this displayed book could fill immediately?
Check the changed case
30 × $25.10 + 70 × $25.30 + $10 = $2,534. At most 30 units meet the limit in the displayed book; actual priority, competing orders and quote changes can mean fewer. The unfilled 70 are not holdings, and an order cancellation or expiry needs confirmation.
Official references for this workshop
Sources checked 2026-10-25. The numerical documents and examples are original fictional teaching material. This source check is not an independent professional signoff.