Saving and investing · Article 23

TFSA vs RRSP: compare after-tax dollars fairly

Compare TFSA and RRSP outcomes using equal after-tax saving costs, consistent investment assumptions and explicit tax rates at contribution and withdrawal.

Published by North of Numbers · · 5 min read

Educational purposes only. Examples are fictional and in Canadian dollars unless stated otherwise.

Start here

How can TFSA and RRSP balances be compared on an equal footing?

Start with the same after-tax saving cost and use the same investment return, fees and time period. An RRSP contribution can be larger for that cost if the deduction’s tax reduction is included in the calculation. Later, ordinary RRSP withdrawals are generally taxable, while ordinary TFSA withdrawals are generally tax-free. Under a simplified model with equal contribution and withdrawal tax rates, the two can produce the same after-tax result. Different assumptions can change that result.

What you’ll learn

  • Equal deposits are not necessarily equal after-tax saving costs.
  • An RRSP balance must be translated into after-tax spending dollars for a fair comparison.
  • Tax rates, benefit interactions, room and withdrawal flexibility are separate variables.

Make the starting amounts comparable

A comparison that puts $5,000 into a TFSA and $5,000 into an RRSP, then ignores the RRSP deduction, does not hold the household’s after-tax cost constant. A comparison that includes the deduction but ignores later RRSP tax has the opposite problem.

CRA describes ordinary TFSA contributions as non-deductible and investment income and withdrawals as generally tax-free. RRSP contributions can be deductible, income generally remains sheltered inside the plan, and ordinary withdrawals are generally taxable. CRA: what is a TFSA, CRA: RRSP overview

Those rules tell us where to put the tax adjustments. They do not tell us which account a specific person should use. The following model isolates the arithmetic so that the assumptions are visible.

Fictional CAD example: equal saving cost, equal tax rates

Assume a household can give up $3,500 of after-tax spending today. Assume sufficient room in either account, an immediate RRSP tax reduction at 30%, no benefit effects, and an identical 4% annual net investment return for 20 years. The return is a teaching assumption, not a forecast.

The TFSA receives $3,500. Its future value is:

$3,500 × 1.04^20 = $7,668.93.

For the RRSP, solve for a contribution whose net cost is $3,500:

RRSP contribution = $3,500 ÷ (1 − 0.30) = $5,000.

The $5,000 contribution creates an assumed $1,500 tax reduction, leaving the same $3,500 net cost. After 20 years, its before-tax value is:

$5,000 × 1.04^20 = $10,955.62.

If the effective tax rate on that withdrawal is also 30%, after-tax proceeds are:

$10,955.62 × 70% = $7,668.93.

The equality is not a coincidence. With the same rate at contribution and withdrawal, the larger RRSP starting amount and the later tax adjustment cancel mathematically. Both accounts shelter the assumed growth within the model.

Why “the RRSP is taxed on all the growth” is incomplete

It is true that the model taxes the full RRSP withdrawal. But it also allowed a larger initial investment for the same net cost. Describing only the final tax omits the starting advantage. Describing only the deduction omits the final liability.

The model can be written compactly. If C is after-tax saving cost, G is the investment growth factor, t₁ is the deduction tax rate and t₂ is the withdrawal tax rate:

TFSA after-tax amount = C × G.

RRSP after-tax amount = C × G × (1 − t₂) ÷ (1 − t₁).

This expression is useful because each assumption has a visible place. It also shows its limits. Real taxes may not apply at one rate across the entire contribution or withdrawal, and tax reductions may arrive later than contributions.

Change the withdrawal tax rate

Keep every earlier assumption but change the effective withdrawal rate. The RRSP’s before-tax amount remains $10,955.62.

Assumed withdrawal rateRRSP after-tax amountTFSA after-tax amount
20%$8,764.49$7,668.93
30%$7,668.93$7,668.93
40%$6,573.37$7,668.93

The table explains sensitivity; it does not predict the household’s future bracket. A lower later rate improves the RRSP result in this simplified comparison. A higher later rate reduces it. If a large withdrawal spans several brackets, the relevant measure is the incremental total tax caused by that withdrawal, not necessarily the highest bracket printed on a tax table.

The refund assumption has practical consequences

The RRSP calculation assumes the full $5,000 is contributed and that the associated tax reduction lowers its net cost. Someone who can initially transfer only $3,500 and later receives a refund has a different contribution timeline. Timing affects how long each amount is invested.

If the refund is spent rather than saved, comparing only the eventual investment balances no longer holds total consumption and saving equal. That does not make spending the refund morally wrong. It means the comparison answers a different question.

Borrowing to bridge the timing would introduce interest, repayment and liquidity risks that this model excludes. The arithmetic is not an instruction to borrow. It is a way to check whether a claimed comparison has silently assumed extra money or immediate access to a refund.

Room and access can change the practical question

Both accounts have contribution rules. Sufficient room is an explicit assumption above, not a conclusion about any reader. Ordinary TFSA withdrawals are restored to room in the following calendar year; a same-year replacement needs existing unused room. CRA: withdrawing from a TFSA

That timing can matter for money expected to move in and out. The investment itself can also restrict access: a registered account holding a non-redeemable deposit does not make that deposit instantly spendable. Account tax rules and investment liquidity are different layers.

The comparison also excludes income-tested benefit changes. CRA states that TFSA income and withdrawals do not affect federal income-tested benefits and credits. An individualized RRSP analysis may need to include how taxable income changes interact with applicable programs. Provincial benefits require their own rules. CRA: TFSA impact on federal benefits

Keep the investment constant while comparing the account

A TFSA holding a savings deposit and an RRSP holding equities do not provide a clean test of account tax treatment. Different investments can produce different returns, risks and costs. Any result would mix the account choice with the investment choice.

For a learning exercise, hold the investment assumptions constant and alter one tax assumption at a time. Then repeat with a delayed tax reduction, different fees or a partial withdrawal. Label every simplification.

Finally, describe the result as conditional: “Under these assumptions, this amount becomes that amount after tax.” That wording is more accurate than declaring a universal winner. The value of the exercise is an understandable comparison in spending dollars, with the tax timing and missing variables visible.

Evidence behind the explanation

Sources & checks

Linked sources were consulted on October 26, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.

  1. What is a TFSACanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-10-26

    Non-deductible contributions, ordinary tax-free income and withdrawals, federal benefit treatment.

  2. Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP)Canada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-10-26

    RRSP contribution deduction, income shelter and ordinary taxable withdrawals.

  3. Withdrawing from a TFSACanada Revenue Agency · Accessed 2026-10-26

    Next-calendar-year restoration and same-year room requirement.

When this article needs another review
  • Changes to TFSA or RRSP tax treatment.
  • Changes to benefit treatment of registered-plan income.
  • Changes to contribution or withdrawal rules.

Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.

About this educational article

Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.

This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.

Read our editorial standards · Report a correction