Start here
Why can two retirees with the same returns finish with different balances?
When withdrawals occur, the order of returns changes how much money remains invested for later periods. An early decline followed by spending leaves fewer dollars to participate in a recovery. Reversing the same returns can therefore change the final balance even when the starting amount and withdrawals match. A simple example demonstrates the mechanism; it does not predict market returns or identify a universally safe withdrawal rate.
What you’ll learn
- Distinguish the average of returns from compounded investment growth.
- Track withdrawals before applying each period’s return.
- Test spending changes without claiming that a cash buffer eliminates risk.
Averages omit the cash-flow path
Two investment paths can contain exactly the same annual returns in a different order. With no money entering or leaving, multiplying the same return factors gives the same ending value. Withdrawals change that relationship because different dollar amounts remain exposed to the next return.
This is sequence-of-returns risk in a retirement setting. The concern is not only whether an investment falls. It is the interaction between the fall, the amount withdrawn and the future growth of what remains. A model that uses one smooth annual return can hide that interaction.
The Ontario Securities Commission's investor-education site explains that volatility affects decisions about selling investments and taking withdrawals. The original example below isolates the arithmetic so the effect can be examined without assuming an actual market forecast.
First remove withdrawals from the example
Start with a fictional $500,000 portfolio. In one path it falls 20% and then rises 25%. In the other, it rises 25% and then falls 20%. With no contributions, withdrawals, fees or taxes, both paths end at $500,000.
For the first path, $500,000 multiplied by 0.80 becomes $400,000, then multiplied by 1.25 returns to $500,000. For the reverse path, $500,000 multiplied by 1.25 becomes $625,000, then multiplied by 0.80 returns to $500,000.
The arithmetic average of minus 20% and plus 25% is positive 2.5%. But the two-year compounded growth is zero, because 0.80 multiplied by 1.25 equals 1. That distinction matters before any withdrawal is introduced. An average percentage should not be casually substituted for a compounded growth rate.
Worked example: withdraw $30,000 at each year’s start
Keep the same fictional starting portfolio and return paths. Now withdraw $30,000 at the beginning of each year, before that year's investment return. There are no other cash flows, taxes or fees. All amounts are CAD; the large returns are chosen to make the mechanism visible, not to represent an expected portfolio.
| Step | Decline first: −20%, then +25% | Gain first: +25%, then −20% |
|---|---|---|
| Starting balance | $500,000 | $500,000 |
| After first $30,000 withdrawal | $470,000 | $470,000 |
| End of year 1 | $376,000 | $587,500 |
| After second $30,000 withdrawal | $346,000 | $557,500 |
| End of year 2 | $432,500 | $446,000 |
The first path calculates as ($500,000 − $30,000) × 0.80 = $376,000, followed by ($376,000 − $30,000) × 1.25 = $432,500. The reverse path finishes at ($587,500 − $30,000) × 0.80 = $446,000.
Both paths distributed $60,000. The gain-first path ends with $13,500 more. The difference does not come from a higher average return or a smaller total withdrawal. It comes from the sequence interacting with the money taken out.
What the early withdrawal changes
After the early decline, the portfolio has $376,000 before the second withdrawal. Taking $30,000 removes about 7.98% of that amount. In the gain-first path, the same $30,000 removes about 5.11% of $587,500. The cash amount is identical but its proportion of the remaining portfolio differs.
The later 25% recovery in the decline-first path applies only to the $346,000 left after spending. It cannot grow the dollars already withdrawn. This is why a subsequent market recovery need not restore the account to the result of a path that had gains first.
The example also specifies withdrawal timing. Taking money at the end of the year would produce different balances. A calculation that changes timing between scenarios cannot attribute the whole difference to the order of returns.
Test spending flexibility explicitly
Now reduce only the second withdrawal in the decline-first path from $30,000 to $24,000. The calculation becomes ($376,000 − $24,000) × 1.25 = $440,000. Compared with the original $432,500, the ending portfolio is $7,500 higher.
The household also received $6,000 less to spend. The improvement is therefore not free money. It combines the retained $6,000 and its assumed 25% growth in the second year. A scenario that celebrates the larger portfolio without acknowledging reduced spending would give an incomplete explanation.
If instead the second withdrawal rises 2% to $30,600, the final balance is ($376,000 − $30,600) × 1.25 = $431,750. Inflation-linked spending is another cash-flow assumption that changes the path. It should be visible rather than buried in a headline withdrawal percentage.
A cash buffer has a cost and a role
Cash or other stable resources may help fund spending without selling a volatile investment at a particular time. But the buffer is part of the household's overall assets, not an extra resource that can be counted twice. Its return, inflation exposure and replenishment rule also matter.
For example, moving money from investments into a reserve changes the amount exposed to market returns. A fair comparison keeps total starting wealth the same and explains when the reserve is used and refilled. Merely adding several years of cash to one scenario gives it a larger starting resource and does not isolate the strategy.
The OSC's discussion of investment time horizons connects investment risk with when money is needed. Retirement contains many spending dates, not one distant date, which makes that distinction especially useful.
What this illustration cannot establish
Two years cannot determine a safe lifetime withdrawal rate. Actual outcomes depend on the investment mix, fees, taxes, inflation, longevity, other income and changes in spending. A series of favourable hypothetical returns is not evidence that a strategy is safe, and an adverse illustration is not a prediction that it will fail.
A useful learning exercise starts with the same total assets and spending goal, then compares several return orders. Reconcile the opening balance, withdrawal, return and ending balance for every period. Identify when a shortfall would occur rather than allowing the model to continue spending from a negative portfolio without explanation.
Finish by describing which assumption caused the difference and what the household gave up to change it. That makes the scenario informative without converting a simplified mathematical demonstration into a personal investment recommendation.
Evidence behind the explanation
Sources & checks
Linked sources were consulted on October 26, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.
- How does market volatility affect your investments?Ontario Securities Commission — GetSmarterAboutMoney · Accessed 2026-10-26
Volatility and decisions about selling or withdrawing investments; the numerical sequence example is original.
- What is an investment time horizon?Ontario Securities Commission — GetSmarterAboutMoney · Accessed 2026-10-26
Relationship between when money is needed and investment risk.
When this article needs another review
- Changes to the example’s return timing, withdrawals, fees or inflation assumptions.
- Any expansion from the two-year illustration to a long-term model requires new validation.
Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.
About this educational article
Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.
This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.