Start here
Why can my personal investment return differ from the return reported by the fund?
The amounts you invest and the dates you invest them affect your personal result. A time-weighted return links investment performance across periods while removing the effect of external contributions and withdrawals. A money-weighted return also reflects those cash flows. Both can be correct, even when one is positive and the other is negative. Before comparing numbers, match the dates, currency, fees and calculation method, and check whether each percentage covers the full period or represents an annualized rate.
What you’ll learn
- A fund’s return and your account’s return can differ because your money was invested for different parts of the period.
- Link period returns by multiplication; do not add them or confuse a cumulative percentage with an annualized one.
- Reconcile cash flows and reporting assumptions before interpreting a difference as an error or evidence of skill.
Start with the question the percentage answers
An investment statement can show a disappointing personal return beside a fund factsheet showing a gain. That difference deserves an explanation, but it does not establish that either document is wrong. First identify what was measured and whose money was present when the gains and losses occurred.
CIRO distinguishes time-weighted investment performance from money-weighted performance that reflects the investor’s contribution and withdrawal timing. It explains that CIRO dealers use a money-weighted method in investment-performance reporting. CIRO’s explanation of investment returns
This article works through one fictional account rather than treating a return percentage as a score. All amounts are Canadian dollars. The investment, cash movements and returns are invented for learning, not a forecast or a suggestion to change contribution dates.
Set out the two-year account before calculating
Suppose Morgan invests $10,000 at the start of Year 1. The portfolio earns 20% during that year. Morgan adds another $10,000 immediately after Year 1 ends, and the combined balance then loses 10% during Year 2.
Assume each period is exactly one year, all investment income remains in the account, and the stated returns already reflect any investment costs. Ignore personal taxes and inflation. The contribution occurs at the boundary between periods, so none of the new money experiences Year 1’s gain.
| Event | Calculation | Account value |
|---|---|---|
| Start of Year 1 | Initial contribution | $10,000 |
| End of Year 1, before contribution | $10,000 × 1.20 | $12,000 |
| Start of Year 2, after contribution | $12,000 + $10,000 | $22,000 |
| End of Year 2 | $22,000 × 0.90 | $19,800 |
Morgan contributed $20,000 in total and finishes with $19,800: a $200 investment loss. That dollar reconciliation is useful before attempting any rate calculation.
Calculate the time-weighted result
Remove the contribution from the performance calculation by measuring each investment period separately. Year 1’s growth factor is 1.20. Year 2’s growth factor is 0.90, calculated from the $22,000 balance after the contribution.
Multiply the factors: 1.20 × 0.90 − 1 = 8%. This is the cumulative time-weighted return over two years. Adding 20% and negative 10% would incorrectly produce 10%; the second percentage applies to a changed base.
The equivalent compound annual rate is 1.08^(1/2) − 1 = 3.923%. An unchanged dollar invested at the beginning and left throughout would grow by 8% altogether, not by 8% in each year. With no later contribution, the original $10,000 would finish at $10,800.
Calculate the money-weighted result
For this example, use the internal rate of return, or IRR: the constant annual rate that reconciles the amounts invested, their timing and the ending value. Let that rate be r.
The opening $10,000 is invested for two years and the second $10,000 for one. The equation is:
$10,000 × (1 + r)² + $10,000 × (1 + r) = $19,800.
Solving gives r = approximately −0.668% a year. Substituting the unrounded rate makes the left side equal $19,800. The negative result fits the $200 loss, while recognizing that not all $20,000 was present for both years.
Simply dividing the $200 loss by $20,000 produces negative 1%. That is a loss divided by total contributions, not the annual IRR. Dividing the loss by the initial $10,000 produces negative 2%, another number answering a different question.
The time-weighted annual result of positive 3.923% and the money-weighted annual result of negative 0.668% therefore coexist without contradiction. More money experienced the losing year than the winning year.
Reverse the sequence and keep the contribution fixed
Now change only the order of the investment returns. Year 1 loses 10%, reducing the opening $10,000 to $9,000. Morgan contributes $10,000 at the same one-year boundary. Year 2 gains 20%, taking $19,000 to $22,800.
The cumulative time-weighted result remains 0.90 × 1.20 − 1 = 8%. However, solving the money-weighted equation with $22,800 as the ending value gives 9.060% a year, and the dollar gain is $2,800.
This comparison isolates the effect of timing. It does not show that Morgan could have predicted the better sequence. A contribution may follow a paycheque, inheritance or sale rather than an attempt to anticipate markets.
Separate external cash flows from activity inside the account
CIRO’s archived MFDA performance review distinguishes money entering or leaving an account from trades inside it. Rebalancing, buying with existing account cash, retained dividends and interest are not new external contributions. Transfers of investments across the account boundary do count. The review also identifies incorrect transaction coding and valuations as causes of reporting errors. Performance Reporting Targeted Review
For a practical check, draw a box around the account being measured. A $2,000 bank transfer into the box is an external contribution. Selling a holding and leaving the proceeds inside changes the contents, not the external funding. If a report combines several accounts, redraw the box around that combined scope before classifying transfers.
Read the statement as a reconciliation
The Canadian Securities Administrators describe annual performance reporting that includes account returns, deposits and withdrawals, changes in market value and rates of return. A separate charges and compensation report helps explain costs. CSA guidance on understanding your investments
For Morgan, the first check is opening value $10,000, plus contribution $10,000, minus investment loss $200, equals closing value $19,800. Then locate the reporting period and method. A year-to-date dashboard is not automatically the same measurement as a two-year annualized report.
Ask which costs are already reflected, whether distributions are included, and which currency is used. Confirm the recorded dates and market values of transfers. Keep statements and transaction confirmations together so a discrepancy can be traced to an input instead of debated through competing percentages.
Compare like with like, and recognize the limits
A fund comparison needs matching dates, comparable investments and a consistent basis for costs and income. For the fictional portfolio, a useful experiment is to apply Morgan’s exact contributions to a comparison investment. That asks what the same cash-flow schedule would have produced there; it differs from comparing two headline percentages.
Neither return measure alone describes risk, tax consequences or progress toward a spending goal. Morgan’s $19,800 might be adequate for one planned purchase and inadequate for another. A percentage cannot supply the missing target or deadline.
Actual deposits occur on irregular dates. A dated IRR calculation uses the applicable day-count convention; do not force every transaction into annual buckets. More complicated patterns of contributions and withdrawals can also produce ambiguous IRR solutions. Ask the reporting firm about its methodology rather than assuming a spreadsheet’s first result must match.
Learning exercise: reproduce both measures
A fictional account starts with $8,000. It earns 10% in Year 1, receives a $4,000 contribution at the one-year boundary, and earns 5% in Year 2. Use the same exact-year assumptions as Morgan’s example. Calculate the closing balance, cumulative time-weighted return and annual money-weighted return.
Solution: Year 1 ends at $8,800. The contribution raises the balance to $12,800, which grows to $13,440. The dollar gain over $12,000 contributed is $1,440. Time-weighted growth is 1.10 × 1.05 − 1 = 15.5% cumulatively, equivalent to 7.471% annually.
For the money-weighted result, solve $8,000 × (1 + r)² + $4,000 × (1 + r) = $13,440. The annual IRR is 7.004%. It is lower because the additional money participated only in the lower-return second year. Recording the contribution date explains the difference more clearly than labelling one percentage right and the other wrong.
Evidence behind the explanation
Sources & checks
Linked sources were consulted on November 2, 2026. The examples are original educational calculations. Source consultation and arithmetic checks do not constitute independent professional review.
- Understanding Investment Performance / ReturnsCanadian Investment Regulatory Organization · Accessed 2026-11-02
Time-weighted versus money-weighted performance and the money-weighted method used in dealer reporting.
- Performance Reporting Targeted Review, July 26, 2021Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (archived MFDA report) · Accessed 2026-11-02
External cash flows versus internal account activity, transfers, valuation errors and transaction coding.
- Understanding your InvestmentsCanadian Securities Administrators · Accessed 2026-11-02
Annual investment-performance information and the separate charges and compensation report.
When this article needs another review
- Changes to Canadian dealer performance-reporting requirements or definitions.
- Changes to a firm’s calculation method, cash-flow convention, account scope, fee treatment or reporting currency.
- Recalculate every example if its contribution timing, period lengths or returns change.
Check the linked official guidance before applying a rule that may have changed.
About this educational article
Published by North of Numbers and created with AI assistance using the sources listed above. This article has not been reviewed by a qualified financial professional. Sources, assumptions and hypothetical examples are shown so readers can examine the reasoning.
This article explains general concepts; it does not assess individual suitability or provide personal financial, investment, tax, insurance, mortgage or legal advice.