NORTH OF NUMBERS · FREE EDITABLE WORKSHEET

FHSA/HBP comparison and evidence checklist

Click any white cell to write. This file works locally; it sends no inputs anywhere. Save a filled copy to keep edits, or print. Values are not calculated automatically in this worksheet; use the linked online tool for calculations.

Open the interactive tool

FieldYour entry / evidence
FHSA opening eligibility—
FHSA qualifying withdrawal eligibility—
HBP eligibility—
Verified FHSA room and date—
FHSA balance—
Proposed new FHSA cash contribution—
Accessible RRSP balance—
Proposed HBP withdrawal—
Purchase month—
Confirmed repayment start year—
Repayment source / evidence—
Evidence checked date—
Cash outside registered accounts—
Closing costs reserve—
Emergency reserve—
Optional tax-effect assumption—
Unresolved questions—

Repayment evidence check · 25 October 2026

CRA’s overview describes extended deferral for first withdrawals in 2026–2028; its detailed repayment page still describes 2022–2025. Confirm the start year from your applicable CRA record before using a schedule. A withdrawal divided by 15 is an illustration, not your assessed minimum.

Compare benefits. Keep obligations visible.

Evaluation fieldFHSAHBP through an RRSP
StructureRegistered savings accountEligible withdrawal program
Core limit$8,000 participation room in the opening year; $40,000 lifetime limitUp to $60,000 eligible withdrawal per participant
Unused roomLimited carryforward after opening; check actual roomHBP does not create RRSP contribution room
ContributionsGenerally deductible when eligibleRRSP deduction rules apply
RRSP-to-FHSA transferUses FHSA room; no new deductionNot an HBP withdrawal
Home withdrawalTax-free when qualifyingEligible withdrawal avoids immediate inclusion as ordinary RRSP income
RepaymentNo repayment for a qualifying withdrawalUp to 15 years, subject to applicable rules
Repayment deductionNot applicableDesignated HBP repayments are not deductible
Missed minimum repaymentNot applicableShortfall generally becomes taxable RRSP income
Contribution timingNo minimum holding period for a qualifying FHSA withdrawalRecent RRSP contributions can face deduction restrictions
No home purchaseReview transfer and closure optionsReview cancellation rules after an HBP withdrawal
Combined usePossible when conditions are metPossible when conditions are met

FHSA limits and deductions: CRA FHSA overview, CRA participation rules.

FHSA withdrawal and repayment treatment: CRA withdrawal rules.

HBP limits and repayment treatment: CRA participation rules, CRA repayment rules.

Source record

Rules checked 25 October 2026. Recheck rules before acting.